General Question

Afos22's avatar

Would HDMI Provide me with optimal video and audio quality?

Asked by Afos22 (3562 points ) December 28th, 2010

My Comcast box is connected to my 47” LCD HD TV with a/v cables. They aren’t regular a/v cables. There are 5 connections. I have an HDMI cable that a bought on amazon. Would the HDMI cable give me the best Video and Audio quality? And what about the worst quality HDMI? Would 5 a/v cables beat the worst quality HDMI cable?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

Neurotic_David's avatar

Very generally speaking, the 5 video cables you have (called component video cables) will provide just as good an audio and video feed to your television as a single HDMI cable will. Audiologists and videographers could argue for hours over the minutia, but for us regular folk, I believe the two are of equal quality.

jaytkay's avatar

Don’t worry about the quality of the HDMI cable. While expensive cables in general are a waste of money, digital cables like HDMI are especially simple – they work or they don’t.

Why You Should Never Pay More Than $10 For HDMI Cables

Not_the_CIA's avatar

I would go with HDMI. And buy the cheapest one you can since digital is digital. All the gold plated connector – monster cable shit is marketing. It is a one or zero. It works or it doesn’t.

http://www.monoprice.com/ is very good and cheap. I six dollar cable there will cost 40 at BestBuy.

jaytkay's avatar

I can also recommend monoprice, I am very happy with cables I bought from them.

And back to the original question – they both work fine but I think HDMI is better because one cable is a lot easier to handle than five.

Here’s a quick comparison:
HDMI Vs. Component

Note that although HDMI supports 1080p and component does not, that is not a big deal, your Comcast box is not 1080p.

Afos22's avatar

Firstly, handling is no issue, for they will be at a resting state behind the television. Also, are the high definition channels 1080p?

jaytkay's avatar

US cable and broadcast HDTV is not 1080p. Sometimes it’s 1080i, but I think it’s mostly 720p.

I think the only 1080p sources for consumers are Blu-Ray discs and some satellite TV.

dabbler's avatar

If both your comcast box and your TV have HDMI use that.
The component cables can’t deliver a better audio signal, and from a cable box the component video won’t be fabulous anyway. So replace the clutter of five cables with one why not?

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther