Send to a Friend

sarahjane90's avatar

EU directives are only capable of vertical direct effect. Do you agree?

Asked by sarahjane90 (1805points) January 16th, 2011

Direct effect is a principle of EU law which allows provisions of EU law to confer rights upon individuals. Individuals have a right to enforce these provisions before a court. Directives are obligations imposed upon Member States, which are left to be implemented by the Member State on their own accord.

However, individuals are only able to enforce directives against the state (vertical direct effect) and not against other individuals (horizontal direct effect). Do you agree with the current law, which only allows for vertical direct effect, or do you think directives should also be capable of horizontal direct effect? If so, what are your reasons?

Using Fluther

or

Using Email

Separate multiple emails with commas.
We’ll only use these emails for this message.