Social Question

ro_bot's avatar

Does sugar slow or stop muscle gain?

Asked by ro_bot (60points) February 17th, 2011

For 3 months I was working out 3 times a week trying to gain some muscle… at the end I didn’t even gain a pound =[

Lately, I haven’t worked out at all, but I have done a little exercise (walks, rollerblading, moving my uncles house) and I’ve been on a “Diet”. Basically, I cut out all crap food, try to eat 3 meals a day, and then binge on Sundays after eating a high protein breakfast (although, I can hardly eat more than a donate and a piece of cake now, haha).

It’s been about a month and I’ve gained 5–10 pounds (I doubt it’s fat because I hardly eat sweets.. well, hopefully it isn’t, haha.)

So, do you think sugars can slow down muscle gain? Sorry this isn’t very descriptive, I’m just looking for your opinions =P

-ben

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

5 Answers

syz's avatar

I doubt it’s fat because I hardly eat sweets..

Weight gain doesn’t come from sweets, it comes from calories. Those calories can come from sugars, carbohydrates, fats, and proteins – doesn’t matter. It’s the ratio of calories in to calories burned that affects your weight.

You don’t describe what your workout consisted of, but if you want to put on muscle weight, then keep up the healthier diet and do plenty of resistance (or weight) training.

Pandora's avatar

It takes longer than 3 months to put on significant muscles unless you were doing it before and it simply got laxed. For first time, it will take a while. You may have not been putting on weight but it doesn’t mean you were not developing muscles in places that are not obvious. I know a guy who use to go into bodybuilding competitions. He showed me pictures of his first competition after a year of training. He looked thinner and leaner. After a few years he almost doubled his muscle build. I know he would carbo load and eat a lot of proteins. Don’t ever remember him eating sweets. I know protein is needed for healthy muscle growth.

abaraxadac's avatar

Sugar is generally considered to be a great multiplier of yeast in the system, as it is yeast’s favorite food. Some sugars, I will caveat that, are much more beneficial than others, with refined sugar and high fructose corn syrup supposedly the worst for you.
The Atkins diet consists of not consuming sugars or breads, and one person I know who actually does in fact have a thyroid problem goes on this plan to lose weight effectively. The breads contain yeast that will feed on the sugars and increase your body fat.
Other than that, sugar is burned by muscles when they contract, as a fuel. It is not used by them to add mass. Several articles I have read say that protein powder does not do as much for you as a simple glass of low fat milk, even chocolate milk, after a workout, because of the way the body assimilates the protein. I have known guys who went with creatine powder to help build muscle mass while working out, and it did well for them; however, when they stopped taking it and working out, the extra mass gained was lost very quickly, and within 3 months or so they were back to normal. Heavy weight lifters in the magazines work out several times a day, take massive amounts of supplements, and have very strict diets, just to maintain their mass.
Each individual has a certain body type that he or she is genetically engineered through their DNA to fit into. You can be stronger or weaker, fatter or skinnier than this type through your lifestyle, but each alteration of your original type must be maintained for a sustained period of time through that lifestyle to permanently change you. My grandfather was limber as hell and strong as an ox at 70 years old, because of the way he lived his life. His wife, my grandmother, was fat and sat around knitting all day, just like she did most of her life. He died 15 years ago, she is still hanging on.
The point being that you can try to change who you are, physically, but keep in mind the continued commitment you will have to make to maintain it, and sometimes it just doesn’t matter, if you happen to have a thyroid problem. I have another friend that works out for a minimum of two hours a day, running three hours straight sometimes, and he just looks really fit, not all that muscular or anything. He doesn’t use supplements, just has paranoia about getting fat.
NO, sugars will not slow down muscle gain, they really have nothing to do with it, unless you count the energy needed to move them around while they are straining at something. They will, however, increase your body fat content.
Muscles strain, they rip and tear, then heal back. When they heal back, with copious amounts of protein and other nutrients, they heal back stronger than they would have without the added bonuses, but sugar is not a building block for muscle tissue. Protein is.

ro_bot's avatar

Thanks everyone for your answers!

Yes, abaraxadac, I’ve though about having a lifestyle routine a lot. Thanks for reinforcing my thoughts on it. If I plan on getting stonger or bigger I will have to be willing to make it a lifestyle change, something I’ll be doing for 10, 20, 50, or 60 years.

I will take all your advice! Continue cutting out crap foods, find a routine that works for me that I’m willing to stick with for a long time, and eat healthier + protein.

-ben

mattbrowne's avatar

It doesn’t. What matters is usage of muscles and the required minimum amount of protein related to it. When you use your muscles their cells burn sugar (glucose -> ATP).

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther