Social Question

johnny0313x's avatar

Is this a fair price for car repairs?

Asked by johnny0313x (1855points) August 19th, 2011

I have a 2000 Oldsmobile Alero that needs new front struts and the rack and pinion replaced. My mechanic said he can do everything with the exception of the alignment for $650.00

I live in Pennsylvania which i’m assuming location has to do with the pricing but I was just wondering if this seems like a fair amount for the work being done. I’m not opposed to the pricing but just want to make sure that I am not being overcharged.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

tedd's avatar

That is in fact a somewhat reasonable price for that type of work. Struts are not very easy to change (well, they can be but its a lot of work). You could probably find cheaper if you hunt around a bit (and it never hurts to look), but you’re not going to find like $200 cheaper (or at least I would be shocked and questioning the quality of the work if you did).

If you have some tools and know how you could probably change them yourself to be honest.

But if you’re set on a professional, that is a reasonable price.

jca's avatar

A good way to figure it out is to ask how much the parts cost and how much the labor will be. The mechanic should be able to break it down for you.

CWOTUS's avatar

Check it out on this repair cost calculator. (For my ‘04 Camry, it suggests that “strut replacement” done in the shop in my area would be on the order of $450 or so. That was for one strut.)

jrpowell's avatar

That seems reasonable.

jerv's avatar

I paid $500 to get all four struts replaced on my ‘85 Corolla; that is without alignment or work on the steering rack by a mechanic that charges $60/hr for labor. That was in WA last year.

When I needed the air suspension in my ‘94 Subaru removed and replaced with conventional struts ’’(which also required new top mounts)—the bill came to $650, and that was in NH about three years ago.

I would say that if they are also replacing the steering rack (which is a pricey part in and of itself; the ones I saw were ~$200) then $650 is pretty good.

FluLess's avatar

That price doesn’t seem too bad. It is fun to get a resolution to these mechanic questions and get back on the road. Maybe since he’s doing the work anyway you can ask for a deal on the alignment.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther