Social Question

icehky06's avatar

Someone, anyone, alter my essay. Por favor!

Asked by icehky06 (896points) April 6th, 2012

I am just about ready to send this essay out to a school and I would love to hear your insight and the alterations you people have to offer. Please be honest! Thank you for the time you are taking out of your day to help me with this.

Earlier this year I watched the movie Donnie Darko for the first time. I sat throughout the entire film captivated and was left with more questions rather than answers, but in a good way. Donnie Darko is centered on the complex idea of time travel. I was truly enthralled by the notions of reality and concepts that I thought only existed in science fiction. Although, I have always been quite fond of myths and conspiracies, I did not expect to become as deeply intrigued as I found myself to be after watching that movie.
A few days later I stayed up researching time traveling and after skimming through websites, I was hooked on the various concepts addressed throughout each site. My mind opened to the mysteries of the universe and the current investigations that scientists are exploring now. Among the many complex ideas, I was particularly attracted to Einstein’s theory of special relativity. In the beginning, I had difficulties comprehending how time was not constant but depend on an object’s speed. After spending much time researching online and watching related videos on YouTube, I have a better understanding even though I have not mastered the idea. Special relativity is such a significant discovery in history that leads to several possibilities, including the prospect of time travel, which really grabbed my attention. As I further researched, I was fascinated to learn about a scientific research conducted in Switzerland. Certain particles approaching the speed of light have been observed to exist for much longer periods of time than their normal lifespan, which is evidence that time travel is not just some impossible, crazy idea. It is bewildering to think that science has the ability to accomplish ideas that I once imagined only for fiction.
Some scientists have already come to the conclusion time travel is not possible, but others, including myself disagree. Time travel is possible, it’s just the conditions to make it happen is hard to accommodate. Time traveling is theoretically possible – we just really cannot accelerate humans nearly as close to the speed of light.
Along with special relativity, I am also fascinated by the theory of worm holes. Worm holes are my favorite time traveling- related topic. Which makes me believe it works because of the space-time. Space-time is curved like a cylinder the top of the cylinder is the same as the bottom a wormhole is a tunnel that goes through the cylinder that leaves you where you started only older.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

rebbel's avatar

I sat captivated throughout…
...was left with more questions rather than answers, but in a good way.
Although I have always been… no comma
...how time was not constant but depend depending on an object’s speed.
...and watching related videos on YouTube, I have a better understanding (now), even though I have not mastered the idea. added now(?) and a comma
...which is seems to be evidence…
...come to the conclusion that time travel is not possible…
...it’s just that the conditions to make it happen is are hard to accommodate.
Space-time is curved like a cylinder*;* the top of the cylinder is the same as the bottom*,* a wormhole is a tunnel that goes through the cylinder that leaves you where you started*,* only older. (I’ve added a ; and two commas) Not sure if that last sentence is very fluent; you might want to redo that one?

These ‘improvements’ are done by an ESL speaker, so don’t take them for granted, please.
I am sure better advice will come along :-)

digitalimpression's avatar

“Time travel is possible, it’s just the conditions to make it happen is hard to accommodate. Time traveling is theoretically possible – we just really cannot accelerate humans nearly as close to the speed of light.
Along with special relativity, I am also fascinated by the theory of worm holes. Worm holes are my favorite time traveling- related topic. Which makes me believe it works because of the space-time. Space-time is curved like a cylinder the top of the cylinder is the same as the bottom a wormhole is a tunnel that goes through the cylinder that leaves you where you started only older.”

Read pretty smoothly for me until this last bit. I would avoid using words like “really”.

I’m not a write by any means, but I’ll take a stab at altering this one paragraph just for kicks.

Well.. nevermind, @rebbel already pointed out the things I would have changed.

icehky06's avatar

Thank you both!

CWOTUS's avatar

As a 58-year-old man I would write a very different essay, but I’ll try to put aside my ideas on content and theme and try to stick to style.

I would suggest leaving out some of the detail you have included, which is extraneous to the ideas you’re trying to present: “earlier this year”; “for the first time”; “but in a good way”. That’s just the first two sentences. Later, “a few days later” and “stayed up”. No one is going to care that you “stayed up” to research; if it’s relevant to the essay that you started the research “a few days” later, then by all means include it. Is it relevant?

I agree completely with @rebbel‘s pickup of the placement of “captivated”, his dropping the comma after “Although” and other grammatical and syntactical changes.

I would suggest re-reading the essay yourself very closely. Then I would suggest rewriting it entirely.

The first question I would have asked is “What is the point of the essay?” I realize that personal essays are part of the modern college application process, but I have to confess that I’m ignorant about the exact purpose or whether a theme is intended.

If part of the purpose is to suggest or display writing style or mastery, then you should “put on someone else’s eyes” and read this as someone other than yourself. Rewrite, rewrite, rewrite. You have no idea how often I rewrite simple responses in Fluther, for example, but I’ll tell you: I do it all the time.

I’m not going to suggest that my writing was much better at your age, but then I hadn’t done so much of it.

Finally, I would certainly rewrite the sentence that “Some scientists have already come to the conclusion that time travel is not possible, but others, including myself disagree.” Aside from the glaring grammatical error – a missing comma after ‘myself’ – the obvious question that any intelligent reader would be left with is: How long have you been a scientist?

wundayatta's avatar

You are sending this essay out to a what kind of school and for what purpose?

WillWorkForChocolate's avatar

Am I the only one that saw the “por favor” and immediately changed essay to ese? Altering an ese could mean jail time.

<stupid giggle>

Trillian's avatar

What @CWOTUS said. What’s the point of this essay? Figure that out and state it in your first paragraph.Then write three supporting paragraphs with one though each. Then state your conclusion in the final paragraph.
Completely drop the word “I”, stay away from passive voice and contractions, and cite your references.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther