General Question

fremen_warrior's avatar

How far does the apple REALLY fall from the tree?

Asked by fremen_warrior (5510points) April 13th, 2013

I am sorry for the size of this post, but I really, really need to rant…

I am particularly interested in your relationships with your parents. As for the why I realised recently that I really have a hard time accepting mine for who they are and it got me thinking whether this means I am a bad person or perhaps it’s natural that we tend to see mostly the faults of our parents… I know this sounds bad when someone says they can’t stand their parents, but sometimes this is just the truth.

My parents are what you can call ‘good people’, though if I hadn’t moved far away from them and reduced contact the way I did recently I’m afraid they would continue to try and steer my life for me, practically telling me to do this, wear that, think in this way, don’t eat that etc. I realize this is what parents normally do to a certain extent but I feel mine are overbearing. They do not accept it when someone has a different opinion from theirs (though they claim otherwise) – in which case they will ridicule you “jokingly of course”... I won’t bore you with the details.

Suffice it to say whenever I finish talking to them I can’t help but feel drained, like I just went through a criminal investigation into my everyday life, and had to defend my motives for everything I do. I swear, I am angry… Really, very few people can ever get me so worked up as my parents can, in a matter of moments. I especially tend to dislike my mother, it seems, who is manipulative, always knows what is best for everyone and gets bored if the conversation isn’t about her (i.e. starts interrupting whenever me and my dad are having an interesting conversation about something she has no interest in) but cannot stop talking when she has something to say about what SHE likes or whatever. Anything she likes I immediately dislike and I feel almost offended if she pretends to be interested in some of the things I like I just feel like it’s all just another trick to seem more likeable. My mother is a master emotional manipulator, something I found out during all the years of bitter quarrels between my parents that I witnessed as a child.

For a long time when I was growing up my parents didn’t know how to communicate properly (understatement of the decade) – they almost divorced because of that. A lot of my childhood was long ugly quarrels, name calling and accusations thrown back and forth with brief intervals of normalcy, and good times. Coming home from school it was common that I found my mother crying or obviously having just been crying and now “dead silent” not speaking to me, my father (who in turn was sitting in another room) and I had to play the role of mediator, trying to figure out what it was this time that they had fought about… The atmosphere was often very tense, I was constantly afraid they’d hurt each other or split up if this continued… It was really a nightmare at times. Often after a fight like this either one of them stormed out of the house and I had to listen to the other’s “side of the story” i.e. monologue, ranting about why the other one was being unjust – and then the other came back, and I had to listen to another rant, from another perspective.

All rise, the family court is in session, fremen_warrior – having witnessed both sides of the story – must now decide who is right and pick a side, an alliance if you will. Were you ever put in a position where you had to side with either one of your parents? Sometimes all the choices you are given are bad. I hated Christmas. Every year we decided which grandparents to spend it with (and it usually ended with a huge quarrel, and me feeling like I betrayed the side I wasn’t visiting that year speaking of which that was the exact wording used by one of my grandmothers when one summer I decided to go to a martial arts camp with my day, instead of spending that time with them and my mother, she (my mother’s mom) basically said (speaking of me) “how could he have betrayed you like that?!” (I was ~ten) It was a freaking mess.

After years of this they finally started to talk better, the fights got fewer and further in between. Nowadays and for about 10 years now they are mostly great together – good for them. Now they behave as if it wasn’t that big a deal, and seem to expect me to be over it all by now. I mostly have gotten over this I think, though it has left a mark on me, something I am afraid will not ever fully go away.

I still have issues trusting people, forming ‘normal’ relationships with others (“if you’re going to grow up to be like your father, better stay single, stay away from women, and don’t screw up some poor girl’s life that way”). And I am hypersensitive to any and all attempts by others to manipulate me, to ‘sway’ me to their side (whether real or perceived)...

As for my parents, what angers me the most nowadays is how much of a ‘hive mind’ they have become – agreeing on 95% of everything, and thus believing their enlightened fantastic view of the world is the supreme freaking truth, although “oh no, everyone has the right to their own opinion of course, and we are never judgmental of course you can do whatever you think is right for you… you want to do what? Then you are a fool. Fine do whatever you want but you are being a complete fool, you should do this this and this, why won’t you LISTEN to us, all we want is what’s BEST for you” or some such bs.

I am sorry for ranting like this, especially since it is commonly seen as impolite, and a sign of a terrible personality, to be talking that way about one’s parents, but I really feel I could not talk to them for weeks at a time and my life would be so much better. I literally feel better when I haven’t talked to them in a while, like a week or two. They just don’t seem to understand that, and almost feel offended if I don’t call or e-mail them for an entire week.

When I come to visit them I can talk to them for a while, a day and a half at most, and that’s enough, I like my parents I respect them for what they have done for me, but on the other hand I deeply despise them for being judgmental know-it-alls (no offence @KNOWITALL :P), who want to know every single detail of my life (yeah and if we have a falling out they then use everything I tell them against me, been there, done that I cannot trust them with my life’s details because come argument they WILL drag it out and use it as an example why I am a moron and I should always listen to them) and seem oblivious to their own at times toxic personalities. I treat them with respect, I like them in a way, it’s just that more often than not they seem to manage to tick me off like no one else can, and if I come to visit, I want to leave come the end of day two….

What about you are your relations with your parents good? Do they ever make you feel this way? Do you think I need therapy? Feel free to share what your relations with your parents are/were like, and what you make of all of this.

Congrats, if you managed to read through the entirety of this monster of a post.

Penny for your thoughts?

Cheerio!

the fremen

There was a similar question here before but the differences are enough to warrant the asking of mine.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

Dutchess_III's avatar

Wow! I read it. Are you afraid you’re starting to act like them? Is that why you asked how far the apple falls from the tree?

fremen_warrior's avatar

@Dutchess_III thank you. In part yes. I’m afraid if I’d ever decide to stay with one person, start a family or sth. this might somehow find its way to the surface. I really wouldn’t want to do this to someone; there is a part of me that thinks that perhaps I really should stay single rather than risk being like them. Let me stress though, I don’t think my parents are necessarily bad people, quite the contrary, they were really bad at communicating though and that was enough to mess things up… I am afraid I might copy their crappy habits :/ Another thing is the anger that my parents still sometimes instill in me. I try to control it, but it can be tiresome. I mean I am an adult I should be able to shrug this off damnit…

marinelife's avatar

Your parents sound awful. They sound very much like my in-laws right down to the very manipulative mother. My husband guarded his life so carefully so she couldn’t latch on to it and use it.

You have the right idea—distance yourself from their influence. Keep the emails to weekly. Keep the phone calls brief and twice a month.

We limit our visits to the in-laws to 72 hours, because that’s all that we can stand. We now also stay in a hotel not under their roof so that we can get away for part of the day.

Do not feel like you should like them, talk to them, visit them. They are poisonous, and you must protect yourself and you life.

Dutchess_III's avatar

The biggest part of your battle is won, @fremen_warrior. You recognize what they did wrong. Yes, you’ll have to work to develop different habits, but once they become habits, it’s much easier.
My mother used to be quite sarcastic and impatient and just say things that hurt and did nothing to help whatever. I always vowed not to be like that. However, without realizing it I was doing it too. One day, when my oldest was about 7, I chastised her for something. Suddenly she said, “You can be mad, Mom, but you don’t have to hurt my heart!” Pulled me up short….
I really saw it clearly in the way she treated my kids too. One day we were visiting and my daughter said she’d heard that cold water boils faster than hot water. My mother, who wasn’t mad about anything else at the time, snapped, “That is the STUPIDEST thing I have ever HEARD!” and proceeded to slam about getting two pots to prove how stupid it was, which, of course, left my daughter feeling stupid.

My son talked about taking a road trip when he was 18. He was about 14 at the time. Mom ripped him up one side and down the other about how did he expect to afford it, it was a dumb idea, yadda yadda, yadda.

Try taking different examples of incidents you experienced, and role play in your head how you could do it differently.

Sunny2's avatar

Leave the bad behind and keep the good. You don’t have to repeat what you received that was unfortunate. Keep your distance as much as you can.
My mom threw tantrums. I decided I would never do that and I didn’t. Not that I was a perfect parent; I can’t claim that. I just didn’t do the things I didn’t like about my parents’ parenting.

JLeslie's avatar

I sometimes feel like I have been run over by a truck when I speak to my father, so I know what you mean when you say your parents can be draining.

I offer some thoughts that in no way means I am questioning how you feel and how they act. Have you ever asked your mom point blank, “mom, do you want me to do XYZ? Is that why you are telling me that?” I say this because children, even 40 year olf children, sometimes feel their parents will dissapprove if they don’t go by their recommendations, but sometimes in the parent’s head they are just trying to give advice, and ok if their adult child decides to do something else. Parents often do not understand the trip it does on their kids when they offer suggestion. Often to the kid, we feel pressure and attempts at manipulating us.

Also, your mom might have a lot of anxiety, and the way she calms herself is to try to control things. Maybe she worries about your choices, worries about you, afterall she loves you intensely I am sure, and doesn’t want you to make a bad decision that will cause you pain. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think her trying to control you is ok, but if you understand why, you might be able to reassure her about your choices. Not that you owe her an explanation, but empathasiIng with her perspective might bring you some calm.

I could be way off base with all of that, I don’t know your parents obviously, they could be a total pain in the ass. But, since you mentioned bad communication in the family, maybe more direct communication will help. Ask her why. What is her goal. you cannot read her mind and she can’t read your, and you all might completely misunderstand each others intentions. You also can tell her how upsetting it is to you when conversations veer off in certain directions and going forward you are going to ask to end a conversation when it is upsetting you. That you fear if you let it go on this way you won’t want to speak to them at all. That by setting these limits, maybe you all can better understand when conversation become stressful.

Just a thought, might not help at all.

Arewethereyet's avatar

Having seen what other flutherites have said at different times about their relationships with their parents I don’t think you are inevitably going to be like your parents.

Both my parents have flaws as do we all, I realize them, I see them, I learnt to live with them.
I left home pretty much straight after high school finished and made my own life, got educated (paid for it 100% myself) got a car, travelled and then bought a house. My parents saw I could do it on my own I owed them nothing and didn’t have to prove myself.
I did things they prob didn’t approve or agree with.

The biggest thing that happened in my childhood was a nasty divorce. Thankfully my parents ended up as friends but it was horrendous at the time and I was the oldest and 10. it did make me very independent though.

My mum had a lifelong obsession with weight and food and every time I visited she’d look me up and down and make a comment about my figure!! Positive or negative I hated it but readied it was her own projection and obsession so didn’t get stuck into her overit, but I must say it did leave scars to this day.

The other thing my parents did was give me a pubic school education and sent my brothers to the posh private school. I loved school and valued highly an education so that pissed me off severely. It’s the reason I send my kids to a private school now I am giving them the opportunity I didn’t get, it’s also the reason I made sure I payed for my degree myself.

All in all yes they left their mark on mylife but I think I’m ok, my mum now has full blown Alzheimer’s and I am her career, she still looks me up and down and thinks she herself is fat, she weighs 50 kg and is micro small and thin!

Bellatrix's avatar

I don’t think you should feel bad about disliking your parents. They are who they are and they have impacted negatively on your life. As the saying goes, we can’t choose our family. I think it’s unrealistic to tell someone ‘but they’re your parents!’. Parents are human beings. They mess up. They have issues. They aren’t always good people. Accepting that’s part of growing up.

I got on well with my dad but I didn’t always agree with him. He did things along the way that left me feeling fairly disappointed with him. My stepmother drove me insane! In my late teens and early 20s I found it hard to be around her. Thankfully, like you, I moved away. In my case so far away we didn’t have physical contact for years. It gave me time to put enough distance between the problems we had and to grow up some more and find ways to resolve my feelings towards her.

I hope you can manage to keep some distance so you can move on with your own life. I doubt you will replicate their behaviours but perhaps some counselling to help you work through all this wouldn’t be a bad idea?

Inspired_2write's avatar

I believe that it is their behaviour that you really do not like, not them.
It is their behaviour that bothers you.
You have a choice to get upset by their antics or not.
No one can argue with you withput your imput. Don’t give them any.
Let them talk, then say ’ you could be right, I will decide on my own” Thankyou.
They are in effect training you for life.
Where ever you go in life there will always be someone or several who will TELL you what to do, in the end IT IS ONLY YOU who decides on your course of action.
Your mistake was thinking that you HAD TO take sides, you don’t.
Accept that maybe that is how they communicated durning stressfull times.

If you feel that you have to explain, then tell both parents that you will not listen to what amounts as THERE PROBLEMS to solve , not yours.
They can only get inveolved If you tell them information about your problems, so stop telling them.
Inform them of ONLY the good things in your life and things will settle on there own hopefully?

You did not mention how old you are so I assume that you are old enough to be on your own?( young adult )?
If still in High School etc then , step away from getting involved in there battle between themselves.
It is there communication style ,probably from before you entered the picture?

fremen_warrior's avatar

Thank you everyone for your personal stories, the examples and words of advice. I only recently begun to think differently about all of this. The longer you treat your parents as a category in itself, not as just another couple of people with faults of their own you cannot really claim to be your own person. It is the realization that you do not have to do anything actually that is liberating. When you grow up in an environment where you get guilted into doing things, on a regular basis, it can be difficult to see this.

My parents have good intentions, I know these people. It’s just that when they get too comfortable in their little world they start to get egocentric – maybe you know the feeling, you haven’t had a failure or a bad thing happen to you in a while you start to believe your own BS about how right you are about everything. Putting that aside, their parents taught them some bad behaviours and coping mechanisms – my mother guilts and otherwise manipulates people to do things her way “she just wants the best for everyone”; my father reacts defensively to anyone who has a different opinion than him on anything (although he is wrong a lot of the times, sometimes pretends to know about something rather than admit otherwise), is immediately judgemental, and resorts to name calling if someone continues to disagree with him.

I can see similar patterns of behaviour in my late grandparents, and it unsettles me. Don’t all of us think we will be better than our parents? That we won’t make the same mistakes? Yet it seems we are bound to repeat them. How do you resist, how do you not slide back into those patterns…

Like you say perhaps the physical distance will help me reshape myself, become more of my own person. I know if I had stayed with them I would not have a working personality at this point. Yet still every time I disagree with them (something I’ve been practicing over the past 4–5 years) I still feel like I am doing something bad, like I am striking against “the only people that actually care about me” and all that. If I let them they’d tell me what to wear for f*ck’s sake. I also have mild OCD – was worse when I was a child but I learned to temper it down as I grew older – it also exacerbates some of these things; e.g. after one of those phone calls they manage to get on my nerves I can’t stop thinking about this sometimes for hours, during which I’m angry, I curse, I feel like hitting someone… One more reason to decrease contact. Perhaps I could talk to someone about this, perhaps I can sort this out on my own with time. I am really happy that I am far away from them now, I am also feeling like a traitor for even thinking that… Crazy life.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther