Social Question

dumitus's avatar

If I talk like people in Pride and Prejudice, will people laugh at me?

Asked by dumitus (657points) September 28th, 2013

First, I’m an English learner. It’s not my first language.
So I ask the above question.
One of the biggest problems I face each time I pick up a movie
to study English with is that I don’t have enough experience to tell whether or not the way they talk is realistic in real life..
Of course I know English in Pride and Prejudice sounds a bit weird,
but I need affirmation..
By the way, do you understand everything people say in that movie, without fast forwarding back?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

CWOTUS's avatar

People may not laugh at you to your fact for attempting to affect archaic English phrasings and vocabulary in general conversation, but they will probably at least look at you oddly. It’s also doubtful that they would understand you, and isn’t that the point of communication? (Worse than “laughing at you” to your face, they may laugh at you behind your back.) However, it’s doubtful that you could pull it off effectively, and then you would feel foolish even to yourself.

Even native English speakers – even in the UK – would have trouble pulling this off in a way that wouldn’t look silly. If you’re just learning the language, then it would be better to learn it well in its modern usage before you attempt historical recreations.

If you want to attempt this, then I would suggest that you join a theater group that specializes in such period productions, where at least you would be among others who would be doing the same thing, and you can learn from them as you improve your own speech and coach others, too.

To answer your last question, I can generally understand the words, but the accents and some of the topical references sometimes throw me.

ucme's avatar

Why aye man, a mean howay, nowt cliva aboot tarkin arl posh like.

Katniss's avatar

I’ve learned that people will laugh at you for damn near anything.
I wouldn’t worry to much about it. Haters gonna hate.

bea2345's avatar

Speak Standard English, such as you hear on the BBC and you will be all right. I am fairly certain, however, that the English that Jane Austen spoke would be very different in pronunciation as well as in grammar and syntax from 21st century practice. Once, in a Linguistics class, I heard a sample of speech of Edward VII of Great Britain (1841–1910). It sounded like a foreign language.

DWW25921's avatar

I understand it. It’s not the greatest example of learning the language though. Try some of the cartoon movies. It may seem silly but they usually speak on a less intricate level that is easily understood. For example, when I went to Ecuador years ago I watched The Smurfs in French with Spanish subtitles. I didn’t know either language but I knew what was going on. It’s the best way to pick up a language I think.

downtide's avatar

That kind of accent is called “received pronunciation” and is still used among the upper classes and in southern England. It’s a good one for people who are learning English as a second language because it’s very easily understood. I don’t think that real people in the 18th century would have spoken that way though.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther