Send to a Friend

plexial's avatar

What compels you to ask or answer questions without requiring or having the credentials and experience?

Asked by plexial (102points) December 30th, 2013

To properly answer any question, a person has to have a comprehensive and authoritative knowledge of, or skill in a particular area. This is called an expert.

Credentials, otherwise known as a Ph.d, coupled with the practical years of experience in that subject are necessary to prove expertise. Standards are equally important. A Ph.d from a prestigious ivy-league university is in no comparison to the lower standards of one that is not. Peer-review increases that standard by culling out illegitimate experts.

An engineer with a Ph.d, but has no years of experience isn’t going to be much of an expert. He/she might, though, when speaking in theory. Likewise, for an engineer with experience, but has no Ph.d.

This question also applies to experts who answer questions of a subject they have no expertise in, such as a doctor answering questions that relate to architecture.

Why do you insist on asking/answering questions with a lack thereof?

Are you overestimating your self-worth?

It seems like a perpetuation of ignorance and disinformation.

Using Fluther

or

Using Email

Separate multiple emails with commas.
We’ll only use these emails for this message.