What do I give him for Valentine's Day?

I’m not sure what to give my boyfriend (he’s 20) for Valentine’s day. I want it to be sweet but not sappy or over the top. Preferably something I could make (I don’t knit or anything…) just because it would be more special and he would be upset if I spent a bunch of money on him. Any ideas? I’m open to anything as long as it’s fairly easy to make and not cheesy.