Social Question

Sneki95's avatar

Can one love his/her country and nation without hating others? If yes, how do you achieve it in this time, where being a patriot seems so hostile and hateful towards other nations?

Asked by Sneki95 (7017points) August 30th, 2016

I was convinced that being a patriot was loving your nation and equally respecting other ones. However, it seems I was wrong: all those people I know that call themselves patriots and say they love their country and are proud of being the nationality they are are either hateful or at least look down on other nations. They justify it with “I am not hating, I am defending what is mine. These people you accuse me of hating did bad things to my people and I can not respect them for that.” There seems to be so much hostility in ideas called “patriotism” and “nationalism”, it all boils down to “I was born X. It is an honour and a privilege to be an X and I am proud of it.”

It makes me wonder: is there such a thing as patriotism I mentioned in the beginning?

Can you love your nation and it’s culture without hating any other?
If it is possible, how to do it without merging in with the first group?

How to be a non hateful patriot among hateful people calling themselves patriots? How to avoid that “us vs them” mindset?

Is there even a point in loving your nation and your country?

Or am I seeing the whole thing wrong?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

14 Answers

trolltoll's avatar

I “love” my country by being a good citizen (or at least trying to be a good citizen) of it. Why should loving your country mean hating other countries?

Sneki95's avatar

@trolltoll

I get that feeling a lot where I live. People who call themselves patriots and say they love their country actively hate on other “enemy” nations. That type of nationalism is quite strong here, and it makes me really jaded about the whole thing.

I wish I could say that I love my culture without having it sound like I imply that I hate anyone else.

trolltoll's avatar

@Sneki95 are you from Texas?

Sneki95's avatar

@trolltoll

No. I’m from Serbia.

flutherother's avatar

“From humanity via patriotism to bestiality” Franz Grillparzer.

Espiritus_Corvus's avatar

You were right the first time Sneki. You can love those things about your country that are lovable and it has nothing to do with any other country. You can also despise certain things about your country at the same time. This doesn’t mean you don’t love it. It just means you see room for improvement. Other people can hate things about your country, too. And you can hate things about theirs. One thing doesn’t cancel another out and everyone has a right to an opinion.

stanleybmanly's avatar

It’s simple. Just refuse to substitute patriotism for abstract thought and you will be fine. Sure I love my country, but patriotism is about emotion, and the emotion has been abused to such an extent that the mere mention of the word should make you immediately suspicious.

Mimishu1995's avatar

The people you described are not patriotic, they are over-patriotic. Those people have unfortunately put their ego alongside with their patriotism. It’s like anything unfavorable happening to their country hurts their ego and they need to defend it. If you like your house so much, does it mean you have to hate all other houses?

Or unless the people you meet are government commentators. In that case I can’t agure with them. They have got to the point where the need to defend their government is so strong their mind just stop working. And there are close-minded idiots too. I’ve met all of the kind before. I’m used to them.

Winter_Pariah's avatar

There’s a difference between being a patriot and a zealot, though it does feel like they oft go hand in hand.

rojo's avatar

Yes, you can love your country without hating others. I think a good example of doing that would be to consider the lyrics to America The Beautiful and what it would signify the citizenry and the world if it were the National Anthem instead of the official one, The Star Spangled Banner
Patriotism, unfortunately, is many times used as a club to beat those who might question the status quo into line. By calling into question a persons patriotism you reduce their worth or their validity of their argument in the eyes of many. One of the best examples of this here in the US was/is the blanket statement “America, Love it or Leave it”. WTF! Is it unAmerican to point out problems that exist or to suggest that perhaps it would be better if we quit interfering in the affairs of others and concentrated on making ourselves and our society a more equitable and sustainable place for all, not just those with political clout or high incomes? Evidently.

kritiper's avatar

Of course you can! In the spirit of good sportsmanship!

Strauss's avatar

There was a Roman senator (I believe it was Cicero, I could be wrong), who wrote about the difference between heartfelt love of one’s county (patriotism)and a blinding love of one’s government (nationalism).

Strauss's avatar

^^To expand on my thought above…

There are a couple slogans that come to mind that illustrate the difference between patriotism and jingoism. During the US’s involvement in Vietnam, the nation was divided between those who supported the war and those who opposed it. On the support side, there were slogans like: “America, Love It Or Leave It!” or “My Country, Right Or Wrong!”

IMHO, these slogans are prime examples of jingoism.

Patriotism, OTOH, is can be much less overt. The patriot is the person who spends time learning about local issues, and then supports the candidate who most closely resonates with his/her feelings on issues. The patriot is the person who volunteers at mealtime down at the homeless shelter, realizing that any person they feed just might capture a glimmer of hope along with the meal. The patriot knows that our strength as human beings is what we have in common, in spite of an accident of birth.

What do we have in common? We all have a desire to live in peace. We also basically have a desire for the common good. We all want to be able to love, and to do something positive for our next generation.

I’m not just talking about the US. I’m talking about the guy from Iraq I chatted with recently; I’m talking about the girl from Vietnam, the cynic from Germany, the cowgirl from California, or the sea captain from the tropical paradise.

I’m talking about our human family.

Lonelyheart807's avatar

I love my country by respecting other’s rights to peacefully protest what injustices are going on…after all, that’s what America is supposed to be about.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther