General Question

gimmedat's avatar

Have you ever wondered if you were partially responsible for the decisions someone else has made in his/her life?

Asked by gimmedat (3951points) November 26th, 2008 from iPhone

Let’s say you’ve given some really kick-ass advice (at least in your mind), or encouraged somebody to do something he/she wouldn’t normally do, and then that person makes decisions that seem totally counter-intuitive to that person’s reality. Would you feel responsible?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

6 Answers

augustlan's avatar

Yes, at least partially. I know I convinced two people to vote for Obama who wouldn’t have dreamed of it otherwise. It means a lot to me that these people believed enough in me to take my words to heart.

IBERnineD's avatar

Possibly, there was a friend of mine who had a girlfriend of 4 years, and when I broke up with my boyfriend of 1 year and told him the reasons -that really only applied to my situation, he used those reasons to break up with his girlfriend. I felt horrible and awkward.

wildflower's avatar

I feel responsible for my input, not the final decision. I have a tendency of arguing both for and against my own recommendations and therefore I’d never assume someone is going on my recommendation alone. They might do the right thing and follow my advice, but not blindly.

Zaku's avatar

Every interaction puts you at cause in some way in the actions of others, which in turn cause other effects. We all are at cause in many things, and are rarely if ever the sole cause of anything, from one way of looking at cause, anyway.

NVOldGuy's avatar

Responsible for what? We never make a bad decision at the time. In time it may seem bad but when we do it’s right in our mind. Also we do have free will. If the person follows your advice it is an act of his/her free will. Just tell them to suck it up and live with their fate.

Jack79's avatar

well I’m pretty sure I have been responsible for at least partially influencing people, since I worked as a teacher for many years. Though I hope it was always for the better. One bad advice I’m dealing with right now is when I told my girlfriend to do something and she got into real big trouble for it. And she’s still in trouble. And now I’m trying to help her get out of it of course and it’s all my fault.

I’m also responsible for what one of my old friends called his company, but I don’t think that counts as negative. He just got the idea for the name.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther