General Question

Mr_M's avatar

Did you notice the subtle way Verizon changed one of their commercials?

Asked by Mr_M (7621points) February 4th, 2009

It’s the one with a family barbecue. The guy used to say “He’s not really my uncle, but he doesn’t owe me money, so he’s a keeper” but now they got rid of the money part and he only says “He’s not really my uncle but he’s a keeper”. WHAT HAPPENED??

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

14 Answers

Dog's avatar

They shortened it to fit a tighter time slot.
A lot of commercials are formatted for different lengths

Sakata's avatar

I was just talking about that a few days ago. Great question.

Tighter time slot? It cut off 1 second so I don’t think that’s it.

eponymoushipster's avatar

probably the current economic situation in the US make such comments “unpalatable”. Or it made him look like a mobster, which, i’ve seen that ad, i thought he was.

or, like @Dog said, it’s been shaved.

Mr_M's avatar

@dog, do you KNOW that for a fact or is that speculation?

Grisson's avatar

I think they took that 1 second and played it during the Superbowl, but I could be wrong.

Mr_M's avatar

I’m thinking they changed it in response to many angry people who OWE money only because of the current economic situation?

Dog's avatar

What I know is that I saw the full version of the commercial last night. Thus if it was censorship the segment would not again air.

Since commercial airing costs $ by the amount of time aired and the time of day aired I have see two or three versions of a lot of commercials.

Here is a story about a different commercial and a quote below from the maker of the ad:

“A one-minute spot that goes into heavy rotation is a pricey venture,” Jaglund said. “Often, a commercial will be shortened to save money. What many viewers don’t realize is the level of skill and artistry required to take a perfectly realized one-minute piece and edit it down to 30 seconds without losing its essence. It’s a subtle and demanding art. Yes, sometimes we have to cut out a cute thing an animated polar bear says, but it must occasionally be done for the sake of economics.”

Sakata's avatar

@Dog That’s perfectly understandable and I’ve seen it myself, but what’s 1–2 seconds really going to accomplish? Also, it’s Verizon and they’ve got more than enough money for advertising which is noticeable based on how many commercials they run and that, as far as I know, they haven’t shortened any of them in this way in the past.

Shortening a commercial from 60 to 30 seconds is normal. A lot of companies do that, and they do it all the time. We’re trying to figure out why a company would only knock of 1–2 seconds. If not for censorship then I don’t see another reason.

It costs money to edit an already circulating commercial too

cwilbur's avatar

You notice that two seconds being cut out because the dialog has changed.

Do you notice if the establishing shot is 5 seconds shorter, and the Verizon logo at the end is displayed for 8 seconds instead of 14, or if the pauses in the dialog have been shortened by 1/4 second here, 1/2 second there?

Sakata's avatar

Since I don’t really care about establishing shots or the company logo… no. As for the pauses, yes I did check for that, but that’s mostly because I like catching editing flaws.

The time the logo is displayed doesn’t really matter as much as dialog being cut. At least not to TV viewers.

fireside's avatar

Yeah, i really doubt that they cut off 1–2 seconds from a commercial. The ad breaks are timed and the commercials are almost always a stadard length.

Most likely, they just edited a few different versions of the spot and have them in rotation to keep it slightly fresh to viewers.

kevbo's avatar

They probably got bad feedback from vocal viewers (or an exec’s spouse) that worried the brass enough to change the ad. I’ve seen it happen before.

I thought it was funny.

rabbidlemming's avatar

As others have pointed out usually they chop commercials to make airing them cheaper. In this case it didn’t seem like a whole lot was removed. Perhaps there was some other reason, maybe so people don’t feel bad when they are watching the commercial because they DO owe people money?

You want people to feel good when they watch your commercials, not guilty.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther