General Question

Damn_Tony's avatar

How do I get her back?

Asked by Damn_Tony (733points) August 11th, 2009 from iPhone

I broke up with her, I feel bad about it now.
It was for a stupid reason anyways. We were out someplace and I was acting stupid. Flirting with other girls just to make her jelous. I had no reason to do it. Then when she was getting really mad I told her to calm down and she started saying a whole bunch of shit and I told her it was over.
She won’t talk to me or answer my messages.
I really blew it this time. What should I do?
If you are reading this I am really sorry.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

60 Answers

drdoombot's avatar

Ignore her. Stop contacting her.

She’ll contact you when she realizes you’re not trying anymore.

Damn_Tony's avatar

@drdoombot How will that solve anything?

drdoombot's avatar

@Damn_Tony I have no idea how the female mind works. I just know that when you give a woman a lot of attention and suddenly stop, she wonders where you went and comes looking for you.

Damn_Tony's avatar

@drdoombot That makes more sense.

Resonantscythe's avatar

@drdoombot That will only work if she has a reason to get back with him.
@Damn_Tony Do you feel like she was happy with you? Could you make this up to her? Do you have what it takes to earn back her trust if she does give you another chance? If not, you may have lost her.

Damn_Tony's avatar

Yes I feel like if she really was
happy with me. I could make this up but I don’t know how, she was really upset. I’d do anything to get her back.

chelseababyy's avatar

@drdoombot That doesn’t work with a lot of girls. Once the guy gives up trying, a lot of us females realize we can get a lot better and that you weren’t ever worth our time.

Buttonstc's avatar

If you really really love her and want her back (not just to soothe your pride) she has to know that you really “get it” If you want to get her attention you should do it in a sincere way that shows her you have put some thought and consideration into the effort.

I would suggest doing it old school. Write her a letter and begin by putting down exactly what you have written here so she realizes that you have come to your senses and it will not be a repeat of the same pattern Otherwise. why should she bother.

Don’t go for the quick fix of phone call or texting or even email. Actually take the trouble to write a letter. It will definitely get her attention in this digital age. And after you have thoroughly apologized, the rest should be a good old-fashioned love letter, as odd as that may sound.

If you want some inspiration I’ll include a quick template below. Just don’t make the mistake of copying it verbatim and trying to pass it off as yours. Acknowledging it as inspiration is ok though.
==========================================================

How do I love thee? Let me count the ways
by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

How do I love thee? Let me count the ways.
I love thee to the depth and breadth and height
My soul can reach, when feeling out of sight
For the ends of Being and ideal Grace.
I love thee to the level of every day’s
Most quiet need, by sun and candle-light.
I love thee freely, as men strive for right;
I love thee purely, as they turn from praise,
I love thee with the passion put to use
In my old griefs, and with my childhood’s faith.
I love thee with a love I seemed to lose
With my lost saints -I love thee with the breath,
Smiles, tears, of all my life! -and, if God choose,
I shall but love thee better after death.
========================================

If you don’t love her that much, then just chalk it up to experience, make a promise to yourself to never treat a woman like that again and move on to find someone else. And if you don’t want to be going through this all again, treat her right.

Damn_Tony's avatar

So if I write the letter do I personally take it to her house
or mail it?
I will treat her right, I’m sure I want this girl.

Buttonstc's avatar

Mail it and then don’t keep pestering her about it for awhile. If she hasn’t acknowledged it in about a week or so, you could legitimately inquire as to whether or not she received it or perhaps it got lost in the mail? Give her time to process things. But, if there is any hope of salvaging this, you’ll probably have some reaction before then.

But, just express yourself sincerely and don’t nag at her Give her some space. You don’t want to be perceived as a stalker. A letter is much less annoying and pressure filled. It is respectful and that is a large part of what you failed at that caused this in the first place—lack of respect.

You can, if necessary, continue to keep writing to her for as long as you have the patience. Flowers don’t hurt either—just don’t deliver them in person. Let her make the next move.

If all of this doesn’t turn it around, you may have to face the fact that you just went too far. But my hunch is that a sincere apology and respect will go a long way to patch things up. Most women realize that sometimes guys can just be immature jerks sometimes.

As I said before, she needs to know that you get it and truly realize why she is so hurt. If you are successful at conveying that, she will in all likelihood give you another chance. Just make sure she doesn’t regret it. :)

Saturated_Brain's avatar

@Buttonstc GA

Be good to your girl, treat her right. There’s no need to go overboard, no need to splurge on a fancy dinner and an expensive gift just to prove you’re sorry. Once she agrees to meet with you again, the first thing you should do is to apologise again in person and promise her that you won’t be such a jerk the next time. And if she forgives you, the romantic in me would then suggest that you hold her hand gently, look into her eyes, and thank her.

What you do next is your prerogative, I’d probably give a gentle kiss and end up with us sitting below a tree resting our heads on each other.

I am such a hopeless romantic….

PandoraBoxx's avatar

You could send her flowers, and have the florist deliver the letter with the flowers.

Focus on how much you care for her, and how you realize that you were a fool to treat a person that you care about so much in such a cavalier manner. And beg her forgiveness for hurting her and being disrespectful of her feelings for you. At this point, she can only agree with you, and that at least establishes a common ground to start talking to you.

littlewesternwoman's avatar

Funny, @drdoombot, that’s what many women think about men…

Sorry, @Damn_Tony, but it sounds like you deserved to lose her. Making someone jealous? That’s no way to maintain a relationship. Leave her be. Learn from your mistake, and try to take a different tack with the next woman…

Judi's avatar

If, after the letter she still refuses to see you, leave her alone and move on. It’s mistakes like this that we grow and learn from. The next girl will get the benefit from this life lesson.

hearkat's avatar

It seems to me that you need to address the issues of why you felt the insecure impulse to try to make her jealous in the first place. If you have problems with your self-esteem, these situations are likely to repeat themselves – whether with her or whomever else you might date.

I have learned from experience, that in order to truly share love, we must love ourselves first. Otherwise, we are always second-guessing the other person’s motivations for being with us, because we can’t fathom why they might want to be with us. So we push buttons and test them (e.g. by making them jealous), and that will wear away at a relationship sooner or later.

If you truly regret your actions and want to change your behavior, you must tackle the source of the problem, so that the patterns don’t repeat. Good luck!

Sariperana's avatar

Suck it up – sincerely.

This is what people do. How people interact. When one cares so much about another, emotions are strong and sometimes get out of hand. It blows up, explodes and then needs a little space to calm down and return to normal again.

If you both genuinely care about each other then a disagreement cannot change that.

Tink's avatar

Why the f…. Did you do it in the first place? You know she really likes you. I wouldn’t be surprised if she didn’t talk to you for a long time! Think about it. Then I’ll call you.

irocktheworld's avatar

Ohhh…my….gosh….I cannot believe she got dumped! Maybe just maybe you took this a little too far with the flirting with the other girls thing.If you want her back then like just tell her how much you love her and how you didnt know what you were doing and make it up to her :)
You’ve done it 2 times already,remember that if you want her back then be good to her or else it will be 3 times in a row and your out! =[]

amoreno06's avatar

i broke up with my ex until the third time when he wouldn’t take me back. he didn’t ask for me back like he did the first two times.
i had been wanting him back for almost a year and a half. he wouldn’t have it.
i was so dumb for doing that.
but i learned form it.
no games in relationships. if you really don’t want someone, break up with them.
but never do it just to “test” them or because of one simple fight. it’s not worth it.
on the other hand, i wouldn’t be with my boyfriend now if my ex and i had stayed together!

Sariperana's avatar

@Tink1113 is it you??? Are you this mysterious woman!?

Sariperana's avatar

@Tink1113 Hun, if he has come into this Fluther world to show you how sorry he is, maybe he really is sorry?

Once you get over the angry feelings, things will start to make more sense. But stand your ground at the same time – respecting yourself is the only way others will respect you.

Tink's avatar

@Sariperana He might… He never did this before. It’s not like him to act this way.

I haven’t talked to him. And I won’t for a while. I’m really hurt. Thanks.

galileogirl's avatar

Forget getting her back, her front is probably more interesting

Sariperana's avatar

@Tink1113 You seem like a smart girl. you will figure this out…

@Damn_Tony Show her you are sorry, telling her can only do so much. Words can only get you so far.

i think you should sing love songs under her window…

Tink's avatar

@Sariperana I’ll try :)

Damn_Tony's avatar

She won’t answer my calls, and when I go to her house she refuses to see me…
I might do that :)

Sariperana's avatar

@Damn_Tony Just dont stalk the girl…

And once you have done all that you can do. Stop.

Once she stops being angry (Angry is a good thing, it means that she cares) Things will come into a fresher perspective. Give her time.

Damn_Tony's avatar

@Sariperana I won’t…

Then she must have really cared alot because she slapped me.

Sariperana's avatar

@Damn_Tony & @Tink1113 Lurve for you both! You guys will sort it out – there is still (however indirect) communication there from both of you guys!

Young love – so sweet :)

Damn_Tony's avatar

@Sariperana Thanks. I hope she forgives me.

Tink's avatar

I also thank you, now I’ll keep a bucket of water next to my window in case he does go singing…

Sariperana's avatar

Hahahah

@Damn_Tony you might want to pack your umbrella…

Damn_Tony's avatar

It won’t matter if I get wet, as long as she hears me…

Sariperana's avatar

@Damn_Tony Thats possibly one of the sweetest things i have ever heard :)

@Tink – Did you hear that? Wow!

Damn_Tony's avatar

That is what brought her to me :)
@Tink1113 You know you love it :)

Tink's avatar

@Sariperana Yeah I heard :)
@Damn_Tony whatever

Sariperana's avatar

Hey dude, at least she responded? better than being ignored!

Damn_Tony's avatar

Yeah, something is better than nothing…

Sariperana's avatar

That’s the spirit! The cup is always half full my friend!

hearkat's avatar

@Damn_Tony: I think it is best to give her some time and space (which means leaving this thread alone for a while) and also working on what motivated you to act that way, so you can explain your actions to her and prevent yourself from doing it again.

Damn_Tony's avatar

@hearkat If that will make her
forgive me, then I will.

Saturated_Brain's avatar

This is like starting to feel like a teen flick happening right before my very eyes..

aprilsimnel's avatar

@Saturated_BrainI know, I’m totally seeing John Cusack in my head! Popcorn’s over here.

PandoraBoxx's avatar

A fitting John Hughes tribute…

wundayatta's avatar

So, let me get this straight. @Damn_Tony is “out” (on a date?) with @Tink1113. Where are they? Not the mall, I hope. So @Damn_Tony sees some other girls, and he thinks to himself, ‘self? Why don’t I flirt with those girls over there, and try to make @Tink1113 jealous. Yeah. Why not? Then maybe I’ll see if she really cares about me. Will she get jealous, or will she not care? I dunno. One way to find out….’

Ok, so it seemed like a good idea at the time. @Damn_Tony is what—14? How many girlfriends has he had? Were there any courses in school to teach him how to be a boyfriend? Or does all he knows come from TV and the movies? Parents? Friends? Church?

So @Tink1113 sees him flirting with the other girls, and she’s like, ‘what the fuck?’ ‘Why is he doing this right in front of me? Does he think I’m not here?’ So she starts fuming, and the anger boils up, and now she’s in @Damn_Tony‘s face giving him what for, and he’s like, “Dude,” (Don’t ask me how girls get to be dudes, but you know how the new generations like to mess up us old farts), “Calm down. Don’t make such a big deal.”

@Damn_Tony is beginning to realize he’s fucked up big time, but he’s still in defensive mode, and is making like he didn’t do anything wrong, and there’s no reason for her to get all bent out of shape. Of course, this is exactly the wrong thing to do, because you just don’t tell a girl what she should feel. What do you know? You aren’t the girl, right? But hell, you’re just 14 years old, and you haven’t even been halfway around the block yet, and you fuck up.

So @Tink1113 is not only feeling insulted, but to add insult to injury, her supposed boyfriend is making like he didn’t do nothing. So she’s getting in his face, and she’s like “Dude” (again with the “dude” stuff, but this time it’s the other way around), “You don’t know how to treat a girl, do you? What the fuck do you think you’re doing? You don’t really care about me. I mean, you’re just dicking around with me, trying to play me, on and off again. Well, I don’t like that shit, and I’m not going to take it.”

And @Damn_Tony, beginning to catch on that that it’s even worse than he thought, but he’s got his pride, too. I mean, he’s a dude (then again, so is she) and dudes don’t take that shit from their bitches, right?

Oh god. Where does this stuff come from? TV? Movies? Maybe they ought to ban the things. At least until kids reach the age of, oh, I don’t know, THIRTY!!!!

So @Damn_Tony is all like, “Bitch, get out of my face. I don’t need this shit. You know what?” He’s started to walk away from her, but he turns around, and his face is like all red—even his ears (that’s the way it is with the Irish, so why not Italians? Not that I know what these kids are)—and so he screams like so everyone in the mall can hear, “Bitch! It’s over! Don’t call me. I won’t be calling you!”

Wow! I mean, wow! So @Tink1113—now her pride is also like torn into little shreds by one of those shredding machines they have in offices? And she thinks, ‘I am never going to talk to him again. I’ma gonna tell all my friends how he is, and let those bitches have him. They deserve him.’

All right. So @Damn_Tony gets home, and he starts to cool down, and think it over, and he realized that he really was kind of deliberately pushing her buttons. He probably doesn’t know why he feels the need to do this. Some kind of insecurity, no doubt. I mean, he’s fourteen for God’s sake. These things happen. And he realizes that he’s really hurt her, and he didn’t really want to do that, because she’s got all these good qualities, and besides, she’s been real nice to him, and showed him fluther and all, which is a real cool site, even if there are all these old farts there…. (do they even think of us as “old farts” any more? Maybe there’s another, more derogatory term?)

So he tries to call her. But she won’t answer. She’s sitting there screening her calls, and she’s glad that he’s suffering because he’s been such a shit. He messages her, and who knows, maybe even e-mails her (do they even know what e-mail is, or is it all Tweets and AIM and Facebook chat???)

Silence. More silence. He’s starting to feel real bad, which is good, since that’s what she wants him to feel. As bad as she felt. Worse even. And now he’s getting all Romeo and Juliet or maybe Pretty in Pink or Sixteen Candles and thinking, you know, boy gets girl, boy fucks up, boy loses girl, and now we’re getting to the boy gets girl back part, so all he has to do is get over there and serenade her under her window with like a guitar and some sad song by Ice T or something (does Ice T do any sad songs? Is it even Ice T?) and her heart will melt, and she’ll appear at the window (does it have a balcony? I mean, what movie are we really in?) She’ll forgive him, and he’ll climb the tree and they kiss and fade to black. Right?

But no. Nothing like that. In reality, she runs back into the house, looking for a bucket to fill with water so she can pour it on her head, but she can’t find one soon enough, and when she gets back, he’s gone.

So he doesn’t know what to do. And then he has this brilliant idea! Maybe he can talk to her by telling the whole world (well, fluther, anyway) about what’s going on, and maybe she’ll see it, and she’ll realize he knows what a jerk he’s been, and she’ll forgive him.

Oh. The drama!

So, it works. And not only that, she gets on the thread, and starts talking about her side of things, and how hurt she is, and they start getting all this advice, and everyone is going all emo about it, and they love to see her be hurt and stand her ground and make him grovel, and then grovel some more, and we all get to see—what will happen?

So is this Jerry Stringer? Or whoever is the latest tell-all host on TV. Does Oprah do this shit? Ellen? Are we all some kind of audience and are there like these ratings or something? Is this even real?

Well. Alls fair in love and war. So they say. But I say that if you put out in public, then you’re fair game, too. Even if you are 13 or 14. I’m old school, I guess. I think people ought to have some shame. Keep things private. It’s one thing to ask indirect, hypothetical-seeming questions, but it’s quite another for the players to “come out” so to speak.

But let’s suppose it’s not an act. Let’s suppose these are real kids with real feelings and they really don’t know what to do, and he’s desperate (because when you’re 14 and this is your first “love” it just gets inside you and it’s all you can think about, and you can’t focus on school (oops, no school, it’s summer), so rewind, it’s summer and this is summer love, and there’s nothing else to do but to get involved, preferably with someone hot, and I don’t know, but I guess girls (never having been one, it’s a little harder for me to imagine) also get all wrapped up in this, and they also really fall in love, and, well, you know….. It’s like Mt Rushmore. It’s like High School Musical. It’s like the quintessential teen-age angsty first love high drama….

Yeah. Ok. As you can see, I’m kind of stalling here, because honestly, I don’t know what to say. Feelings have been hurt on both sides. Does fault matter? Can apologies be accepted? Surely there is more back story here than we know, and there are probably things that bear on the events and maybe will determine the ending, but we simply don’t know them.

Do we want them to get back together? Is it true romance? Is it like @Sariperana says, and if he gives her time, she’ll cool off, and maybe be able to talk to him, and then put this behind them? Are these kids just experiementing and learning how to deal with strong feelings? Are there lessons here for real life? I mean, for the future?

Just how seriously should we take this?

So people start making comments about how much like a movie it is. So cliched and all.

@Damn_Tony starts making brave statements. He act cocksure. “I’ll sweettalk her. I’ll tell her she knows she loves it.” Yeah. That’ll make her feel good. Again with the knowledge of what’s going on inside her. He vows to undergo any test she places on him (getting wet, anyway).

We haven’t heard from @Tink1113 in a while. Maybe she’s getting uncomfortable being in the public eye. Maybe there’s some kind of counter, like when we’re in a TV audience, and they are constantly measure whose side we are on, and who we are sympathetic to, and all that.

But this is part of the problem, I think. @Damn_Tony is acting too macho. He’s not really listening to her. He’s listening to some kind of movie script in his head. And she gets it a bit. It’s confusing, but she sees, to some degree, that he doesn’t get it, and he’s not listening. But does she realize that maybe he’s doing it out of insecurity? Or because he has no idea what else to do? Or is he really that way? One of those guys who always got his way?

Ok. Therapy? We love to urge people into therapy. But can you go to couples therapy if you aren’t a couple? And does teen love deserve to be taken that seriously?

Oooo. What if we get to play couples therapist? Anyone got a license to practice? Hey! We don’t need one. Fluther is open for anyone. So long as they don’t, like, break the rules of the moderators. But I forget. Is @Tink1113 the daughter of one of the moderators? Will she act to protect her daughter? The thot plickens!

Well. Time—maybe it doesn’t heal—but it does make the pain fade a bit. If @Damn_Tony is contrite enough, and @Tink1113 is forgiving enough, maybe they’ll get another chance. Still, the drama—seems like it’s getting in the way. Drama has a way of making people into archetypes, and that kind of hardens their positions and make them act in ways they might not otherwise act.

Can we blame TV and the movies for some of this? Can we blame parents (well, not if one of them is a moderator) schools? Who fell down on the job? Or is it inevitable, like some greek tragedy? Is it destined to be a train wreck? What would Gilbert and Sullivan say? Rogers and Hart? Disney?

Well, stay tuned. Don’t go away. Don’t touch that dial (for those of you who grew up with clickers, believe it or not, in the old days you actually had to drag yourself off the couch, walk over to the TV and turn the dial in order to change channels). Enough provocation.

What happens next?

Guys?

Tink's avatar

Wow Daloon!! You got most of the story right, except he didn’t cuss at me, it was the other way around. He’s 15 and I’m his first girlfriend. No I am not the daughter of a Moderator.
Lurve your answer though.

wundayatta's avatar

Ah well, it was only fiction, anyway. In my story, @Tink1113 is the daughter of a moderator. Doesn’t it add that certain “je ne said quoi?”

Damn_Tony's avatar

@Daloon
We weren’t at the mall, it was the park. I did it because I found out about another guy she use to like.
She told me about him and I don’t know if she still has feelings for him. She says she doesn’t but I don’t know.
I mean, I do believe her but my guy instincts just go crazy!

Yes she is my first girlfriend, I didn’t know how to act in a situation like this.
I shouldn’t have had done it anyways.

hearkat's avatar

@daloon: I just want to point out that my original statement was before I knew the kids are young teenagers. Yes, insecurities are a part of the process of adolescence, but I still recommend that someone in that situation try to understand what fueled the emotions that triggered the regrettable actions, to learn from experience. No one mentioned therapy or counseling, that I noticed.

@Damn_Tony: It is good that you recognize that you were reacting to your concerns that she might still have feelings for the other dude (yes, I am old enough to be your mother, and I have been using the term “Dude” since I was your age). Those are questions that we can never answer… we can only take the other person’s word for it, and have faith that they are being sincere. I still struggle with this when dating someone new. That is why so many people will tell you that trust is a key component in a relationship.

Damn_Tony's avatar

@hearkat Thanks, I am going to trust her words, the other guy shouldn’t matter anymore. I’m content now.

wundayatta's avatar

Damn! What is it with these people? Trying to take fiction and make it like it’s real?

Trust. Big issue.

Security about one’s self. Big issue.

Give yourselves a break. Give each other a break. You care a lot. Let that be good enough. You haven’t had enough experience to really have perspective on this. So I’m telling you that it’s good enough that you each are trying. Also, it’s far better to assume people are acting in good faith, then to assume there is something underhanded going on. Don’t play games in your head going over and over what someone said and wondering what it meant. You’ll drive yourself crazy doing that.

Talk to each other. Find out what happened instead of jumping to conclusions. Be as honest as you can be. Be kind. Be kind. Be kind.

Damn_Tony's avatar

She just called me.

hearkat's avatar

@Damn_Tony: Yay! I wish you both the best.

Damn_Tony's avatar

I really appreciate all the advice.
Thanks guys!

tiffyandthewall's avatar

@daloon you are my favourite author.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther