What to buy him for our 5th anniversary?

I forgot! I have been so busy planning our daughter’s birthday party and getting her Halloween costume together that I forgot about getting him a gift. It isn’t until Friday, so I still have some time, but he is so difficult to buy for. I need ideas!

He still has gift cards that he got years ago, so that is out. He loves to watch football, but… neither of those things seem very anniversary-ish. Sentimental gifts are appreciated, but end up tucked in a drawer or gathering dust on the dresser. He has 4 or 5 watches, wears no jewelery.

This is our 5th anniversary, traditional gift is wood – but I’m not particular about that.