Social Question

Just_Justine's avatar

"He's Just Not That into You" from the female perspective, what would you title it?"?

Asked by Just_Justine (6511points) April 6th, 2010

I remember when this book first hit the headlines, because it caused a certain irritation in me. This book seemed to imply that men called the shots, and women were desperately trying to interpret signals in order to hook a mate. It also implies sexism in its most basic form, women all want relationships, and men are generally “just playing the field”. To add insult to injury it also implies that males need to give females guidelines to their quirky behaviours so that females can understand that in some instances they are just being used for sex or a pass the time fancy.

Now of course not all women want a relationship, some women also play the field. I am sure men have met women who do and are probably more puzzled than their female counterparts are. The role reversal of this plays out everyday.

To me this book should have been called “If you are psychologically inept and cannot read general signals of human behaviour then please read this manual”.

Personally if I met a guy and phoned or texted him I would wait for a reply. If he didn’t reply neither would I. If he didn’t call me for two days I would move on, because I have a lot to move “on to”. If I was confused by his signals I would ask him outright. It’s called “basic communication”.

A good perspective on this train of thought is, how would this be interpreted in the lesbian, gay, and bisexual communities? The very same signals occur and can be misconstrued. How then would this book feature in these communities?

If you were to change the title of this book, what would it be, or if you were to write the female equivalent what would the title be?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

34 Answers

Trillian's avatar

@Just_Justine Titles like this irritate me too. I’m not a part of the lesbian community, though I did have a girlfriend for about 18 months.
Fifty or sixty copies of this book would make a nice fire.

fireside's avatar

How about:

“She’s Just Not That Into You”

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

That book is beyond stupid. Pleas don’t write another one like it.

chyna's avatar

“She’s Too Busy to Figure Out His Stupid Signals”

njnyjobs's avatar

how about: Fugedaboutit and gitoutahir!

Exhausted's avatar

I did not see the movie or read the book. I don’t like mind games, I think they are childish and result in nothing but problems. I am much more direct. I know what I want and will work to accomplish it regardless of whether someone else wants to jump on board or not. Since I have this mentality, I want to find someone else that is of a similar mindset so we can communitcate effectively. I am weary of the struggle of relationships and have no patience for mindgames anymore. To find them a source of entertainment is a sad state of affairs.

Coloma's avatar

I’d change the title to ’ How to spot emotionally fucked up individuals without losing your sanity.’ lol

lilikoi's avatar

“To me this book should have been called “If you are psychologically inept and cannot read general signals of human behaviour then please read this manual”.”

I completely agree, based on seeing the movie not reading the book. Ginnifer Goodwin’s character in that movie was so clueless! But then, I have friends that were like that, too….

Coloma's avatar

@Exhausted

I so agree!
My last dating ‘adventure’ involved a 48 yr. old ‘man’ that actually said to me, ( after all the appropriate flattery and proclaimations of how awesome I was, pursuing me for months…and me, being very clear and direct about what I did and did not want to happen….

Saying, and I quoate…. ” If you arn’t really ready to put out the time and effort to date me, lets just not go there as I do not do on again/off again situations.

His response..” I want to date you at LEAST once a week and that is not even enough!”

2 ‘dates’ later he pulls the distancing trip and when I confronted him he said ” Well, I don’t like to make plans and and I’m not very good at it.”

BUT….‘I don’t want to break up with you! ”

Oookay….told him that if he wasn’t into making plans that it just was’nt going to happen, lol…and that saying one wanted to date someone but did not like to make plans was like saying one wanted to lose weight but eat donuts for dinner!

Allow me to help you with your indecision…...we are NOT dating! lololol

IBERnineD's avatar

There already is one, and it’s really good! It’s called, Be Honest—You’re Not That Into Him Either

rahm_sahriv's avatar

It is just a movie, just a book. Not everyone thinks from all perspectives or finds being politically correct enticing.

It was a plot device, or so I assume, having never read the book or seen the movie. If it bothered you, there are plenty of other books and movies to choose from.

filmfann's avatar

@Just_Justine Did you read this book? JW.

Just_Justine's avatar

@filmfann no I found the title too annoying.

lucillelucillelucille's avatar

I would call every book on that subject,“It’s Not You,It’s Me” ;)

filmfann's avatar

I thought not. I think your point of view might change if you read it.

CMaz's avatar

“THE MAN IS ALWAYS RIGHT, YOU JUST NEED TO FIGURE IT OUT.”

lucillelucillelucille's avatar

@ChazMaz -That’s the best book title ever! LOL ;)

tranquilsea's avatar

@ChazMaz I just spit my tea all over my screen as I burst out laughing.

going to find a soft cloth

phillis's avatar

I get yer point, Justine. I have a strong aversion to games of this nature. You either like me, or you don’t, and you’re free to leave if that’s what you want. If you are unable to appreciate what I bring to the table, then it’s a mismatch with no bad guys. Sayonara. I think these games (and books written with specific instructions on how to play them!) are a construct stemming from generations of body language garble. Why don’t we just say what we mean? Since when is it a crime to ask for your needs? Good grief.

janbb's avatar

She ain’t gonna play with your balls, sweetie!

Neizvestnaya's avatar

“They’re Just Not That Into You- a manual of basic communications in the world of text, e-mail, chat and anti social real world.”

doctiresquire's avatar

he don`t like me…wah…wah wah…would be a great title for those without any thing else to do besides read a book

phillis's avatar

@doctiresquire How’s that bedside manner working out for you?

MorenoMelissa1's avatar

I would title it as “Leave him alone and find someone more compatible with you”.

JackiePaper's avatar

a woman would title it “I’m just a bitch who likes cock in my mouth….the richer the better”

Coloma's avatar

@JackiePaper

Is that so? lol
Well…it’s a wrap!

phillis's avatar

@JackiePaper This is your brain on ceiling wax…......

JeffVader's avatar

How about….. ‘You Ain’t Gonna Get Some’

CodePinko's avatar

Some people call the shots. Sometimes these people are men. Sometimes these people are women.
Relax.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@CodePinko It’s not a 50 50 thing, though. And I don’t think she was being ‘uppity’ what have you.

CodePinko's avatar

I didn’t say it was a 50 50 thing.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@CodePinko well that’s what Just Justine was alluding to.

saint's avatar

She’s Just Not That Into Your Checkbook

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther