Question

iRemy_y's avatar

How can i measure the acceleration of wooden cars being rolled down a hill?

Asked by iRemy_y (150points) | asked 1 week ago | 14 responses | “Great Question” (0points) | Flag as…

For our science fair my project is the “the effect of the shape of a car on the aerodynamics” and my adult sponsor said, “its not enough to build models and time their speed down a hill, like the pine wood derby… you have to find a way to measure the acceleration of the models down the hill.” I’m in 9th grade so i haven’t taken physics yet. can somebody help me figure this out? i read like 20 articles on Wikipedia and totally confused myself.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

Answers

NaturalMineralWater's avatar

Place tape or chalk or some kind of marker across the path of the wooden car. Get a stop watch and take note of how quickly the car travels in between the marks. Toward the top of the hill the times will be slightly higher whereas after time.. the car builds up its maximum speed and the times will even out. This will give you some idea of the acceleration because of the variation in times.

Or .. is that not what you are looking to do? lol

iRemy_y's avatar

@NaturalMineralWater That’s what i was thinking but he mentioned some sort of formula involving the angle of the hill, and the time the car takes to go down. i would guess it also includes the weight of the car. Unfortunately he didn’t specify the formula, which is why i need help…

Ivan's avatar

@iRemy_y

You can easily calculate the acceleration of the car in an ideal situation, meaning no friction or air resistance. But that doesn’t seem to be what your teacher is looking for.

iRemy_y's avatar

@Ivan If i need to my neighbor is a high ranking boy scout leader. i could try to convince him to allow me to use a pine wood derby ramp indoors and alter anything i need to. I have a dehumidifier if that helps and I’m almost positive i can get hold of a shop room to build the wooden cars and get them accurate.

shrubbery's avatar

Do you have access to a ticker tape device? That can help you to calculate the acceleration.
But for what he sounds like he is asking, you will need to know the angle of the slope they are rolling down from the horizontal. If you can do that, I can help you.

iRemy_y's avatar

@shrubbery Yes I’m pretty sure i can figure out the angle. Most I will most likely be using a standard pine wood derby ramp which look like this: http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~mdevine/pinewood/pinewood_derby.html unfortunately they are curved at the bottom… which is the hard part that i need help on. If it is not possible to do, or requires too much effort, i could try rolling them down my hill which i can find the angle of, or better then that, build a small wind tunnel with a fan, build the cars, place them in there, throw some color sand or drops of paint and video it. then make observations on that.

shrubbery's avatar

Ok, that should be fine, give me a few minutes, I’m gonna try and draw a diagram :)

shrubbery's avatar

So here’s the diagram
The F with what looks like an 11 next to it is The Force parallel to the slope. The F with what looks like an upside down T next to it is the Force perpendicular to the slope.
The forces acting on the car are mg (mass x gravity) and the normal force of the slope on the car Fn. The force of the trolley on the slope, F perpendicular, is equal to Fn so they cancel out. So F parallel is the thing that contributes to the car’s acceleration.
from diagram, using sin/cos/tan rules, F parallel = mgsinθ
m = mass of car
g = gravity (9.8m/s^2)
θ = angle of slope from horizontal
F = ma
therefore ma = mgsinθ
a = gsinθ
So now you have a way to calculate the acceleration.
To calculate the time taken, you need to measure the displacement (distance travelled) of your car. On the derby slope, I’d recommend measuring the displacement like this from where you car starts to the point where the ramp starts to curve.
Your car starts from rest, so the initial velocity, symbol u, is 0m/s
Your acceleration, symbol a, is what you just calculated, in m/s^2
Your displacement, symbol s, measured as in diagram, in m
Your time, symbol t, is unknown, in seconds
The equation used is s = ut + ½a(t^2)
Rearrange to make t the subject and voila, you have the time taken for the car to travel the measured distance!

shrubbery's avatar

I’m just thinking though, because your experiment is about “the effect of the shape of a car on the aerodynamics” you might have to go into friction… and that’s even more complicated. hrm.
If you change the mass of the car by changing the shape then you could argue that the mass is what causes difference in acceleration, not necessarily the shape, because if you change the shape but keep the mass constant, by the above formulas the acceleration of the car will be the same. This is because the formulas are assuming that you are in a frictionless vacuum, which kind of defeats the purpose of your experiment. Perhaps you should talk to your teacher again about what you need to do. Or am I reading too much into it?

iRemy_y's avatar

@shrubbery HAHA! i feel so stupid after reading that post like seven times and not getting half of it… i think i get the basic idea but i just emailed my teacher about the wind tunnel idea… if that works then my only problem will be measuring the speed of the wind, which should be no trouble at all. hopefully the idea goes thruogh. if not i’ll show him the post to see if that’s what he wanted. thanks!

Shuttle128's avatar

The best way to fix differing masses is simply to add mass to make sure they are the same. I used to do this when I made pinewood derby cars back in the day. I used lead (though that may not be terribly safe) and melted it down and poured it into holes drilled in the car in order to maintain the maximum weight. Lead is toxic so I don’t recommend trying this by yourself. There may be a non-toxic alternative however using a wind tunnel test would eliminate the differing mass problem.

I’m an aerospace engineering major and I can tell you that the best way to determine how the shape of a car will effect its performance is by doing a wind tunnel test. Most wind tunnels will allow you to measure both lift and drag on a model. The drag would indicate the amount of force opposing the motion of the model at a certain wind speed (which you would select) and the lift would indicate how much normal force would be applied to the model due to the aerodynamics. The normal force would have some effect on the frictional forces so this cannot be fully neglected. You may find that the force is very small, but you can’t really know until you test.

I had a nearby university in junior high that allowed me to use its wind tunnel for a few minutes to collect some data for a science project of mine. It’s definitely worth looking into, the experience is definitely worth it.

iRemy_y's avatar

@Shuttle128 I think I’m going to end up building the wind tunnel. Then its just a matter of building the car models, getting the tunnel together, and reading up on lift and drag. anything you can tell me that would help me study them? Or could you tell me how to measure them?

shrubbery's avatar

@iRemy_y don’t feel stupid, I have trouble grasping it and I’m doing 12th grade physics. Sorry I couldn’t make it any easier for you to understand.
I reckon from the sounds of it the wind tunnel is the way to go :P
@Shuttle128, wow, I want to do aerospace engineering next year!

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question about something? Ask Fluther!