Stuff about unlvrebelx
unlvrebelx’s awards
Comments
Questions
-
2 days ago
Great Question (0
)
-
1 week ago
Great Question (3
)
-
3 weeks ago
Great Question (0
)
Answers
-
2 days ago
Great Answer (0
)
-
1 week ago
Great Answer (2
)
-
1 week ago
@RedPowerLady “But my question to you is how is dressing up like Indians respectful?? You simply cannot honor a people if they are saying ‘when you do this it disrespects our culture’ ”
…The answer to this is, I need to know who “they” are ? I’ve done extensive auditing of Native American Tribes’ financial affairs….from the Pala and Pechanga tribes in California, to the Paiutes in Las Vegas, NV, the Coushattas in Louisiana and the Oneidas in Green Bay, WI.
Guess what? Even the tribes themselves can’t agree who “they” are….some tribes have become so greedy that you could be 100% of the tribal blood and they’ll tell you your not because of a recent bylaw they created.
Regardless, I can tell you that opinions on this issue of “disrepect” vary. Some feel any outsiders portrayal of their culture(s) is disrespectful. Others teach “outsiders” their rituals and sell to outsiders their ritualistic clothing and other items…knowing full well it will be “worn” by the outsider…and many of them do this not driven by greed, but by education…teaching the outsider about their culture.
The fact of the matter is that any and all cultures and peoples will have malcontents and those that will misread actions by others as negative to him/her. In my opinion, this issue can’t be simplified. You have to take each issue as it arises and judge it according to the actions and mindset of those involved. Furthermore, being disrespectful is relative….one may even go out of their way to attempt to be RESPECTFUL and his/her actions may be received as DISRESPECTFUL….so break out the philosophy books and debate that one until your blue in the face, but my opinion is that disrespect is when one blatantly, intently, purposely OR is grossly ignorant in their actions.
Innocently ignorant and those with pure intent should never be considered “disrespectful”....even if they dress up as an “indian” and it offends 100% of all Native Americans…if their intent was the opposite, they’re not being disrespectful.
By the way….my wife’s grandfather is ½ chicksaw and my cousin (foster cousin, I guess) is a reknown Navajo dancer and artist (Kelvin Yazzi).....my wife’s Grandfather, because of the connotations and the way he was treated as a child in Oklahoma (where he was raised) was always embarrassed and denied his ancestry….so my wife and her family have always understood the need to be respectful of others’ cultures (especially Native Americans). On the other hand, my cousin has always been opposite, and even though his family sent him to be raised by “white” family in a “christian” home, he always held on to his culture and never allowed it to be disrected…so I feel I’ve had a lot of experience with this issue.
Great Answer (3
)
-
3 weeks ago
Great Answer (2
)
-
3 weeks ago
Great Answer (2
)
Browse all of unlvrebelx's answers…