General Question

ah020387's avatar

Help with sentence?

Asked by ah020387 (49points) November 24th, 2010

Whcih is more correct:

He mentions this first then follows it up by mentioning the rest.

OR

He mentions this first then follows it up with mentioning the rest.

?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

15 Answers

MyNewtBoobs's avatar

Technically, the first, but it’s really awkward. Is there another option?

gailcalled's avatar

I second the first answer. ^^

Blueroses's avatar

I might go with something more like
He mentions (specific) first and follows up with his other points.

Hobbes's avatar

You also repeat the word “mention”, which is usually not advised when writing any sentence.

MyNewtBoobs's avatar

@Hobbes And it’s a weird tense. I’m not sure what it is (third person, maybe?), but I’d go more with something like “He mentioned (blank), then followed it up with (blank).”

Gamrz360's avatar

Yeah I’m with Papayalily is there another choice?

ratboy's avatar

He mentions this first, then follows it up by mentioning the rest.

Jeruba's avatar

Neither, because “then” is not a conjunction. You need “and then.”

If my choices were as limited as yours seem to be, I would write this:

  He mentions this first and then follows it up with a mention of the rest.

JLeslie's avatar

As other people have stated, I would not use mention twice in the sentence.

@Jeruba I would say most people would not use a mention, I guess it depends on the audience. What do you think? It seems like if we can change the options; add and and a mention; might as well change the sentence even more and create a better sentence altogether.

Jeruba's avatar

@JLeslie, as posed, the question makes me think that these constructions are not wide open for rewording. A little more context and explanation would have helped. That’s why I stayed close to the originals, and not because there’s much to recommend them. You’re right that they could be greatly improved by rewriting.

I prefaced my rewording by saying that this is how I would put it. I can’t speak for most people. There are, however, times when it is not only acceptable but preferable to allow a repetition. Repetition of a key expression can be an effective rhetorical device, as you will notice if you think of certain memorable lines from famous speeches.

Without knowing the rules under which the OP is operating, I think that’s about all we can say by way of response.

NanoBiscuit's avatar

here is an example i would use.. He mentions this first and follows up about this with that.

gailcalled's avatar

That sentence would be clearer (a relative term here) if it read, “He mentions this first and follows up with that about this.”

That said, I will refrain from mentioning how muddled that is about this, or do I mean that?

NanoBiscuit's avatar

If that is about this, then this must be first to mention, or is this just about that, and that would then be first about this..

Response moderated (Unhelpful)

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther