Meta Question

troubleinharlem's avatar

Why isn't there an @all thing yet?

Asked by troubleinharlem (7981points) December 4th, 2010

I mean, you have @username and such, but only for people who have posted earlier in the thread. Why isn’t there one for @all where everyone would get a notification?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

J0E's avatar

No one ever gets a notification. If you want to speak to everyone don’t mention a specific user.

El_Cadejo's avatar

What would be the purpose? The whole @ feature is to link to specific posts. How would such a thing even work?

augustlan's avatar

As @J0E says, nobody gets a notification when a response is directed at them. Lots of people wish that was a feature, though.
As @uberbatman says, when you click on a red ”@so-and-so” link, it will take you to the last answer from that person in the thread. Where would an ”@all” link lead to? I do use ”@all” sometimes, it just doesn’t make a red link when I do.

marinelife's avatar

Posts addressed to @ all do not have an @ sign in front of them. That is presupposed.

erichw1504's avatar

@all… there, you’re welcome.

J0E's avatar

@all you’re doing it wrong.

El_Cadejo's avatar

@J0E cheater.
I see what you did there, sneaky bitch :P

breedmitch's avatar

Speaking of doing it wrong…

I was under the assumption that the @ feature was to be used specifically to address another user’s post in a thread, not just to refer to another user in general.
Eg.

“I was talking with @augustlan the other day and she said…” Wrong

@marinelife What do you mean by presupposed?...” Right

Am I wrong or right?

El_Cadejo's avatar

@breedmitch I would agree with you. When I say stuff like ” I was talking to breedmitch about blah blah” I just try and bold usernames since im just talking about you and not something you said in that specific thread. Otherwise id use the @

Jeruba's avatar

@breedmitch, that’s exactly how the convention was explained when the linked @ feature was introduced, and some did stick to that use of it. But others immediately began using it for all references because I guess that made sense to them or they thought they were supposed to. Maybe they just didn’t distinguish between a third-person mention and a second-person direct address.

I was a holdout for a long time for the same reasons you just explained, but after a while I caved because it does make it clear when you’re referring to a username and not just typing some weirdly spelled word. Also it makes them stand out in a thread, in case you’re scanning for someone’s name. So I think this is a case where usage trumps logic and the custom has evolved at variance with the original intent.

LuckyGuy's avatar

Wow! I had no idea! I thought the @Jeruba was to merely draw attention to the name.
I never know it took you to a specific post! Gosh!
Now I’ll have to figure out how to bold text easily.
OK. Got it. But, color is so much more dramatic.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther