Social Question

chelle21689's avatar

When should you break the "no contact" rule with your ex?

Asked by chelle21689 (7907points) January 26th, 2011

I’m thinking of doing “no contact” with my ex that just broke up with me a few days ago. I want to break the habit of talking every single day for the past 5.5 years. We’ve been good friends for 2 years before we dated, he even helped me through heartache once. Since the break up, he’s been contacting me trying to be friends…but I can still feel the pain between us when we skype and talk…he isn’t happy and neither am I.

I told him about “no contact” last night and he got really upset because he thinks I’d disappear forever for good. He then asked if he could please just try it out for a week and see…and if he could call me when he needs me because I’ve been his confidant over the years and he talks to no one else about his feelings. I didn’t know what to say because I don’t want to regret making him think I wasn’t there for him.

He asked how long will I not contact him. I said I didn’t know…honestly…do I contact him when I don’t love him anymore? When there’s no more pain? What do I do? What if I love him after a year and still don’t feel ready to contact him then I’d lose him as a friend.

I did tell him that no matter how many months goes by, when I do contact him and he doesn’t want to be friends then he never truly wanted to be friends but wanted me as a comfort pillow. I feel that even if we keep in touch right now…there is no guarantee we won’t drift.

Final questions
How do I know I’m ready to contact him?
When do you know you stopped loving them?
What if I regret no contact and things get worse for me?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

chelle21689's avatar

I’m scared to death of this…I feel that I may not be strong enough to resist urge to contact him or reply if he contacts me.

LuckyGuy's avatar

Congratulations! You have taken the first step on the path to your new life.
Good luck to you.

marinelife's avatar

I think this move is a good, healthy move for you. If you are talking to him every day, then you are emotionally invested in him and the relationship. It will be too hard for you to move on.

You contact him again when thinking of him makes you smile, but does not cause pain.

You stop contact now, and then begin to move on with your life. Meet new people, take up new activities. Start over in your life without him. You fill your life with new things and new people so you don’t regret the no contact thing.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

Be honest. Say you understand his fears but you simply don’t have an answer as to whether this no contact rule will mean you’re out of his life forever. You need some distance from the breakup and once you have it, I think you’ll be able to more clearly decide how to be friends with him.

nebule's avatar

I think no contact is necessary after break-ups because there’s so much of that ‘I just need to be with someone’ stuff going on and you reach for the most obvious and needed person.

Personally I’d give it a few months and the likelihood is that if you’re meant to be together the relationship will be different, changed, anew but what is actually most likely is that you will have moved on with your life and although still hold a special place for him, you’ll know that it’s not a good thing to go back to. I’ve been sucked back a few times in various relationships but you just have to learn to be really honest with yourself, which is so much easier said than done!

If after months you really regret no contact..contact him. And I don’t think you ever really stop loving someone that you truly loved… but you have to see the reality of the person – you break up for a reason and you have to keep that or those reasons in mind… not your ideal of what and how you would like things to be like for you…. He is not the person you want him to be but the person he is…(that’s probably just my stuff here!) god I could talk about this subject forever!

Kardamom's avatar

Because this breakup kind of came out of the blue and you’ve been together for such a long time (and because your ex can’t seem to articulate why he feels differently now), I think you need to have some kind of “no contact” situation with him, but give it a time limit. Maybe 6 months, maybe a year.

Right now you are hurting. If he just keeps popping in and out (but considers you to be a friend only, now, and not his girlfriend) then he is just using you for the convenient bits (you talking to him and offering support) but not fixing the situation. This is one of those situations where he either needs to “crap or get off the pot.”

It’s not fair for him to put you in a situation where you are basically trapped by “false intimacy.” You know that you are still in love with him and would prefer that you were still together in the regular way that you were before. For some reason, he feels differently now, but doesn’t want to give up all the goodies, but can’t give you any real relationship or intimacy. That stinks!

You have a few options. First, I would ask him if he would accompany you to a couples therapist to get to the root of “his problem.” Which may be the fact that he is going off to a foreign country with the military, or it could be that he has simply fallen out of love with you, or he could have met someone else (that he’s not telling you about) or it could be something else, or a combination of all of the above.

Ask him if he wants to make a future with you. If he says yes, then ask him to go to counseling with you. If he says no or he isn’t sure, then you need to step back from this relationship and tell him that you are exiting the relationship and you would prefer a “no contact” situation for 6 months or a year (you need to decide, but it should be for at least 6 months, or else you will be too tempted to contact him and you won’t go about your business). Let him know that there should be no contact of any kind ( no phone, letters, e-mail, texting or getting in touch with your friends and family to check up) unless there is a dire emergency (like he is dying, NOT something like he is feeling lonely and sad).

During the “no contact” period, you might want to consider going to a therapist for a few sessions on your own, just to deal with the sadness and grief and anger over this situation. Tell your close friends and family members what you plan to do and let them know that you are going to try to keep busy with hobbies, work, other friends, fun family events, and trying out new experiences (things that you always wanted to do and now have time for) and that you will exercise regularly, and eat nutritious food every day and you will avoid sulking or drinking or smoking or talking about the breakup and you will not think about or talk about about the “what ifs.”

If you meet somebody (or already know somebody) that you would like to go on a date with, go. Have fun and don’t ever feel like you are cheating on the ex. Everything that you do from this day forth is part of your future, not part of your past. If you meet someone that you like, gently explain to them that you are a little gun shy and give a very VERY brief description of your last relationship and then take it slow and easy.

During the “no contact” phase, don’t sit there and mark the days off the calendar until you can speak to your ex again. Simply go forward and live your life. One or both of you might change your minds about whether you want to be together down the line or whether you want to continue living separate lives. If he comes back after a year and says he want to get back together, then it’s up to you to make that decision. But you should demand at that point that you won’t even consider taking him back until you have gone through a round of couples counseling. If you do decide to get back together, you have to make sure that he is good and clear on what happened, why he decided to break up with you, what major changes he has made in his life and he needs to realize how much he hurt you and how he will nurture this “new relationship” and that he can’t just go back to exactly the way things were (or else they will end up exactly the way they are now, again).

Now, go and make yourself a big batch of home made vegetable soup and start making plans for this weekend? Do you want to visit the art museum? Or maybe check out that new little bistro downtown or go see a movie with some gal pals? Or maybe you want to take your little cousins to the zoo or plan a weekend in Vegas trip with your friends or contemplate planting a vegetable garden in your yard. Either way, we fluthers are here to help you move forward :-)

nebule's avatar

@Kardamom just so much lurve for that!

chelle21689's avatar

Kardamom, therapy? Haha, we were long distance so I can’t really attend any of those with him. Honestly, I do want to contact him or see him before he deploys if we’re both not seeing anyone because I think I’d regret not seeing him one more time before going to war. Anything can happen and it’s dangerous out there.

I don’t see us having a relationship in a year when he’s deployed, going on mission trips, language school, or whatever/wherever the army sends him.

I just hope if we don’t get back together that we can be good friends like we once were.

BarnacleBill's avatar

It really has to come in the form of “I love you, and saw myself married to you. You love me, but want to be buddies because you need me. I will talk to you when I am able to get past seeing my future and your future as the same thing. That’s not now. I don’t know when. Perhaps when I meet someone else that I see myself having a future with.”

chelle21689's avatar

It’s hard, cuz I talked to him tonight again…we’re so open and honest about our feelings and we never play games. We talked about how we felt, but even though he’s sad he can not go back to the relationship and hope his feelings will come back. I asked “Do you think your feelings changing was meant to be?” He said “The funny thing is, I feel like it wasn’t meant to be” and that the break up made him feel like a part of him was missing to move forward easily.

Talking about how we felt made me feel better and now I am starting to think that “No Contact” would be a bad idea.. I’m afraid we’ll never be able to talk again if I do no contact for months! At first he begged me not to do this but then he later said “Do what you need to do…I’ll be able to handle it” Ugh, YEARS ago I didn’t want to date a friend because I was afraid of this…and now it’s happening.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther