Social Question

tedd's avatar

Would you take job "security" or career advancement?

Asked by tedd (14078points) February 9th, 2011

I am going to an interview tomorrow at a Medical Examiners office in another city. I’ll spare you the long details of how many interviews I’ve gone to in the city (Pittsburgh), and the love life reasons why I initially applied to those jobs, yada yada yada.

Basically it comes down to this. The position is at a Forensics office. My dream profession is to be a Forensic Scientist/Investigator. This position would be a one year contract position (so no benefits) with the Medical Examiner. It would be part time, with varied hours, some of which could be completed at home. The position would not actually involve doing any Forensics, but would rather be to prepare their lab for a new national standard/audit that they need to meet. HOWEVER, it would be a foot in the door in a Forensics lab, and if I did a good job its not crazy to assume I would be strongly considered should an actual Forensics position open up in the future. Thus far I have applied to probably a dozen different Forensics labs for ACTUAL Forensics jobs (over the last year and a half or so) and have landed only one of them (which I turned down for reasons we won’t get into here). Monetarily I wouldn’t make nearly as much as I do now with this job. In fact they don’t even have a rate yet, it would be negotiated. But even if I got a raise from my current pay by a couple dollars the best I could expect would be a solid 10–20 thousand less than I make now. This means I would HAVE to find a full or part time job to supplement the income (by at least 10–20K). Also I would have to go on my parents insurance, which I will no longer be eligible for in August at my 26th birthday. I would also probably have to put my student loans into deferment for 2–3 months until I could settle down all the moving costs (I paid about 15k into my student loans last year, interest and principle combined).

Currently I have two jobs. I am a SR Lab Tech doing basic quality control work in an Analytical Chem Lab. I have worked here for a year and a half, initially as a contract worker and then hired on permanently. The work is easy, in the Chemistry field, the pay and benefits are great, and the people are all very nice. It unfortunately has pretty much zero career advancement possible though, especially in Forensics. I also have a part time job tutoring an autistic boy. The pay for that job is great, the work is rewarding, and the family and co workers there are awesome. But again it has no career advancement possible, especially since its not really in my field at all. I am scraping by on a lot of my bills with my current combined income, but that is mostly thanks to my student loans. If you took them out of the picture I would be VERY well off. And the money is secure, I’m not likely to lose either of these jobs unless I choose to, and I’ll probably continue to get marginal raises as time goes by.

There are other issues that are weighing on my mind (girls, friends, moving to a new city in another state, money, etc), but I’m trying to look at this ONLY with whats best for me and my career.

I have an idea of what I am going to do, but what would YOU do? Opportunity, or security?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

chyna's avatar

You are relatively young, so I think I would put aside the year to get my foot in the door and the learning experience under my belt. Since it is the field you want to be in, this could be your “in”. Doing a job I love would mean more than money. Trust me, I was in a job I hated for many years. You could be a waiter on the side or still tutor to make up the difference in salary.

john65pennington's avatar

It all comes down to whether or not you are a gambler. Opportunity vs. Security? I would take the secured job in a heartbeat. Why? Because this job will always be there. People always die and sometimes under suspicious reasons. As your time progresses, in the ME office, so will your salary and benefits. Someone, like police officers, have to be there to fill this position.

Gambling? Don’t do it. Take the secured job, like I did. I have no qualms about my years in law enforcement. I loved it and one day you will make the same comment.

glenjamin's avatar

@chyna I agree. You are not saddled down with a wife or a family yet, so I would definitely take the opportunity to do what you love to do, even if it is not a guarantee down the line, it could open other doors for you in the future. I would take the risk now when you’re young because if I was in your position I would take security over opportunity simply because I have to think of my family now. You just have to think of you—go with what will make you happy.

marinelife's avatar

Opportunity—all the way!

Coloma's avatar

Yep, I vote for opportunity as well.
Remember, there is no such thing as ‘security.’ Period.

Maybe the job would be ‘secure’ for a few years, a few decades, but…ultimately, ‘security’ is an illusion.

Plenty of people get the boot from their supposedly ‘secure’ posistions.

Besides, ‘security’ resonates with stagnation for me, but, I have always been much more motivated by freedom and creativity than money and security.

Each to his own, but, I think growth opportunity is much healthier than mouldering away in the safe zone.

blueiiznh's avatar

Go for it!!!
If you wish to make it more obvious, sit down and list out a pros and cons for each condition. This may make it easier for you.
Listen to your heart and gut on where your passions can take you in this new opportunity. They don’t come along often and with a passion and desire and good work ethic, the temp/contract status can change. Even if the funding is only approved for a specific term, doing a great job for them will give you exposure, experience, and worst case references.

If all is equal and you are still undecided, listen to you heart and gut.

Good luck and congrats on even the potential!

wundayatta's avatar

I would keep the current job and look for something that both is an opportunity and pays me more. I think going for “opportunity” is not so much opportunity, anyway. Besides which, it’s asking for trouble if you go to Pittsburgh. Yeah. I think you’d be pretty much sticking a knife in your stomach if you went with “opportunity.” You can do much better. There is no need to put yourself into jeopardy as an auditor. Sounds dreadfully boring, too.

mattbrowne's avatar

Depends on the circumstances of your life. How many kids? How secure is the job of your spouse? Do you own your home? And so forth.

tedd's avatar

@mattbrowne No wife, just g/f. No kids. Do not own a home.

mattbrowne's avatar

@tedd – Well, a calculated risk would favor career advancement in this case, in my opinion, because it involves an opportunity.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther