Social Question

Seelix's avatar

Who's your unconventional celebrity crush?

Asked by Seelix (14862points) August 10th, 2011

You know, someone who’s not really your “type” or someone that you might not ordinarily find attractive.
Someone who’s just got that je ne sais quoi that no one else has.
Someone you might be a little embarrassed to admit you have a crush on, maybe?

Any unconventional celebrity crushes out there?

Me, I’d marry Steve Buscemi in a heartbeat.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

60 Answers

BeccaBoo's avatar

I have always had a secret little crush on Jean Reno, after i watched him in that awsome film ‘Leon’. He is soooooo sexy! LOL

JilltheTooth's avatar

Christopher Guest. The funny-tude of him just makes me giggle.

Blackberry's avatar

Rose Mcgowan and Helen Mirren.

Jude's avatar

I really don’t crush on celebrities.

BeccaBoo's avatar

Got another one…. Idris Elba (he has got the sexiest voice ever!!)

Joker94's avatar

Definitely Uma Thurman, without even thinking.

Jellie's avatar

Allan Sugar

rebbel's avatar

Barry White

OpryLeigh's avatar

Martin Clunes His acting talent and compassion for animals make me find him very attractive even though, looks wise, he’s no oil painting.

Jude's avatar

Just thought of a few. A young Adam Sandler. I also like Andy Samberg.

I love my Jews.

Jellie's avatar

Niles from Frasier (the show)

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

Jude, You just made me think of the Schlitz Gay commercial from SNL.

Scooby's avatar

Pink…. she rocks…. :-/

bob_'s avatar

@BeccaBoo For a second I thought you had written Janet Reno. I was all “whoa, now that’s unconventional.

Cruiser's avatar

Tina Fey! lol!

QueenOfNowhere's avatar

Hmm.. Nicholas Cage… I like men, really. Them being celebrities make it even easier :D So it’s hard to answer this question!

Russell_D_SpacePoet's avatar

Helen Mirren. She is something else.

Imadethisupwithnoforethought's avatar

Felicia Day. Something crazy sexy about her.

redfeather's avatar

Andy Samberg and Jonah Hill

lucillelucillelucille's avatar

Robert Shaw…..actually,he IS my type.
I like Steve Buscemi alot too,come to think of it

Hibernate's avatar

Queen Latifa. I never understood why I like her though.

MilkyWay's avatar

After starting to watch movies a lot lately, I’d say I have a crush on Ben Affleck.

KateTheGreat's avatar

Anthony Hopkins. Ohhh yes. Only old man I would date.

Blueroses's avatar

I’m really drawn to unconventional actors, particularly the ones who can play a bad guy with a sense of humor.
Bill Nighey
Christopher Walken
Zachary Quinto
Michael C. Hall
Tim Curry

Kardamom's avatar

Tony Shaloub (from Monk)

David McCallum (from NCIS)

Simon Helberg (from The Big Bang Theory)

Garrett Wang (from Star Trek the Next Generation)

JilltheTooth's avatar

Psst, @Kardamom : Garrett Wang was Harry Kim, from Voyager. Yes, I am just that geeky to know that off the top of my head. :-)
And I love your list!

Kardamom's avatar

@JilltheTooth OMG! You are so right. I was just watching STNG last night and that’s why I put that down. Also, I was trying to decide whether to list Garrett Wang or Bent Spiner (from STNG) because I find them both extremely hot! LOL

P.S. Simon Helberg reminds me of a young Ringo Starr! Squeeeeee!

JilltheTooth's avatar

And Monk. Oh, god, Monk! I love Monk!
Oh, and Ilya Kuryakin!

Kardamom's avatar

@JilltheTooth You have no idea how much I loved Monk. His mannerisms and nervousness and germophobia reminded me a lot of a fellow that I loved a long time ago. I cried many tears while watching that show, especially the ones where they talked about Trudy, his wife. God, I’m going to start blubbering right now.

JilltheTooth's avatar

Oh, good grief, @Kardamom , we’re just the Goober Girls today!

jca's avatar

Tim Robbins (Susan Sarandon’s ex) is someone who I think looks pretty un-celebrity like. I think he’s cute!

MacBatman31's avatar

Katy Perry and Ke$ha

Pied_Pfeffer's avatar

It’s a toss-up between Graham Norton and Dame Edna Everage. I’d follow both of them around the world if I could afford it. Dame Edna’s alter ego, Barry Humphries holds no interest.

Seelix's avatar

@Kardamom – I also have a huge crush on Data. Not so much Brent Spiner as himself, but as Data and Lore? Totally.

JilltheTooth's avatar

Oooh, @Seelix , the whole good twin, evil twin thing…very hot.

ddude1116's avatar

Audrey Hepburn.


@Jude Me too.

I like Amy Winehouse.

redfeather's avatar

Aziz Ansari

tranquilsea's avatar

Jon Stewart

martianspringtime's avatar

Dean Martin. Is he unconventional? I’m not sure. The first time I saw him – after listening to him for quite awhile – I was shocked because I’d expected him to look different, and I thought he was really unattractive. But now I’ve acquired a huge crush on him.
Also, Alan Rickman. But a lot of people find him attractive too, it’s just odd because he’s old enough to be my grandfather.

tranquilsea's avatar

And Steve Martin.

Kardamom's avatar

@Seelix Yes, it’s Data specifically who I love. He’s like Spock with a heart.

sorry I seem not to be able to type anything correctly these days, I meant to write Brent Spiner

MilkyWay's avatar

Ookay, I didn’t deserve those 2 GAs. Ben Affleck is not unconventional. (slaps forehead)
Sorry guys. I have a crush on this guy here. Bradley James. Eeek!

everephebe's avatar

Unconventional huh? The first person I can think of is Jayma Mays, I’d love to make her pb & j every day that would be hot. I’d bake the bread and make the jam and peanut butter from scratch of course.
Is Maggie Gyllenhaal “unconventional” because I’ve seen her in Secretary Stranger than Fiction and…

Kardamom's avatar

I forgot to put down Guy Fieri from Diners Drive-ins and Dives. He’s a cutie and I just love his down to earth style (not that excited about his clothes, though, I’d rather see him in jeans and T-shirts).

And Bill Engvall from the Blue Collar Comedy troupe. He’s funny and handsome.

Blueroses's avatar

Oh yeah. Guy Fieri is fun. I have a little thing for Alton Brown too .

Kardamom's avatar

@Blueroses Me too! He’s a super smarty foody dudey.

everephebe's avatar

^^I like the word thusly.

MilkyWay's avatar

Hey, does @everephebe count as an unconventional crush??

everephebe's avatar

Not a celebrity so… No^

Blueroses's avatar

A new Q just reminded me of my little crush on Jason Mewes. He always makes me laugh.

Seelix's avatar

@Blueroses and I were just talking about Kevin Smith movies, and I had to add Randal of Clerks and Clerks II.

Also, Kevin Smith, for that matter.

Blueroses's avatar

@Seelix As long as it’s clear that you NEVER go A to M

JessicaRTBH's avatar

I call him a celeb because I feel he’s more a celeb than a Dr. but either way he’s my crush
Dr. Drew haha
and on the other end of the spectrum . . .
Howard Stern

OpryLeigh's avatar

I have recently developed a crush on Katey Sagal in Sons of Anarchy!

Kardamom's avatar

@JessicaRTBH Oh Yes! Dr. Drew Pinsky. He’s a handsome fellow isn’t he? He has a very soothing voice, too.

Deklandb's avatar

These are all great choices! No shame at all! I love carrie brownstein from portlandia, funny chicks are super sexy. I also would do anything for susan surandon, sigourney weaver, and katy segal, who are all in their 50’s and 60’s.

VenusFanelli's avatar

Vincent Cassell

Answer this question




to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther