Social Question

nikipedia's avatar

Should you write a letter of recommendation that's lukewarm?

Asked by nikipedia (27669points) October 18th, 2011

Suppose, hypothetically, one had an assistant who was applying for a graduate program that requires letters of recommendation.

Let’s say the assistant has been totally acceptable. He did what he was told, and made only minimal screwups. But it stopped there. He never seemed very invested and did the bare minimum amount of work expected.

Now he is asking for a letter of recommendation. You are willing to write it, but you know it is not going to be spectacular. Do you agree to write it? Warn the person it is only going to be so-so? Or decline altogether?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

9 Answers

Judi's avatar

I was in a similar situation. In my case, it was an apartment manager. She was very good at the math but had no people skills. She was actually quite a bitch.
I just stuck with the facts and the numbers. I didn’t even coment on her personal skills. I gave it to her and let her decide if she wanted to use it or not.

njnyjobs's avatar

I would seat the person down and tell the person what I might write. If they are okay with what I had communicated to them, then that’s what’s getting written up. If they object, then I don’t write it up.

Hibernate's avatar

Well if I had to do it I’d write it but with a side note “he really needs some improvements”.

smilingheart1's avatar

I see it along the lines of @njnyjobs. I would ask the requestor what he/she was expecting me to write and then chat on those points and state what I would be “willing” to write.

SpatzieLover's avatar

I’ve done exactly what @Judi wrote above. I was honest. It’s up to the individual to decide to use the letter.

marinelife's avatar

I would write it as you noted above. the assistant has been totally acceptable. He did what he was told, and made only minimal screwups. (Maybe leave out the only did the minimum). Then, I would add anything else positive that I could add: he got along well with others. He always greeted each day with a smile. etc.

gailcalled's avatar

@marinelife; OMG, the kiss of death…he got along well with others. He always greeted each day with a smile. etc.

Dutchess_III's avatar

Agree with @marinelife! Just exactly what you told us, only change the wording just a tad! Yes, it’s OK to write a luke-warm letter of recommendation. If he doesn’t like it, maybe he’ll do what he needs to do next time to get a great recommendation. Well…to expound on that…it wouldn’t be doing him any favors to write him a glowing recommendation that he didn’t deserve.

geeky_mama's avatar

@nikipedia – I would decline as tactfully as possible.

In fact, I have done this before. If I can’t write a glowing recommendation about some facet of their performance I’m not doing them or anyone else a favor trying to write the recommendation. If the best you can say about him was that he was “meh”—not worth the time to put it on paper.

For example, I had a super talented colleague who was on the Aspergers spectrum and used to have loud outbursts of cursing in the office. I actually ADORED her – I found her talented, honest to a fault, super-intelligent and genuinely funny and likable. However, in the wrong role (think: customer facing meeting, sitting near phones where our customers might hear her expletive laden rants) it wouldn’t be good for her OR the company. I can, and did write a recommendation for her—because she is talented and worth any accommodations a corporation might need to make.

The unpleasant and unprofessional acquaintance who has reached out to me on Linked In and is fishing for me to provide a recommendation? No.Freaking.Way. That person is toxic and I refuse to provide even a potential link via LinkedIn to my contacts.

I look at it as this: it’s MY reputation. It’s a letter of Recommendation. If I can’t actually recommend the person..well, I’m not going to put my name out there for them.

Last but not least a cautionary tale. My dearest friend in college planned to do a post-grad Geology program after her undergrad. She went around getting letters of recommendations from her professors—especially the professor who had acted as her adviser and for whom she had done oodles of research. This professor (another woman) had praised her for her research and had USED it to publish papers (essentially written by my friend). She more or less claimed work done by my friend (the undergraduate) as her own. Based on this (her professor’s glowing praise and encouragement for her to pursue a Doctorate in the field) she requested a letter of recommendation.
Shortly after my friend had a change in circumstances and instead decided to work (this was nearly 20 years ago mind you—when one could actually FIND work out of college) instead of continue on to grad school. When she no longer needed the Rec Letters for her application she decided to open and read them.
The female adviser professor who heaped praise on her had written the most hateful letter calling her “not cut out for graduate studies, actually – barely a passable undergraduate student” and a “dim bulb” and other discouraging things. Meanwhile she continued to be sweet as pie and request further research assistance to my friend’s face. Nice, eh?

So..if you think that there is any chance you would share both the positive AND negative about your assistant…bear in mind they might just end up SEEING what you write. Although it should be confidential and intended for their school of choice’s application committee..it might just end up being read by the assistant rather than the intended recipient .

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther