Social Question

ZEPHYRA's avatar

What would make a 44 year old man who wanted a serious relationship with a view to it leading to marriage suddenly change his mind?

Asked by ZEPHYRA (21750points) October 29th, 2011

Can you imagine someone suddenly for no obvious reason changing his mind about a serious relationship? There is no argument involved no mention of anything, just a weird, inexplicable change literally from one day to the next. No third person is involved in this decision. It is almost as if the person has a split personality.

Even stranger is the fact that he had been the one who had initiated the whole thing, made promises of commitment and opened up the channels of communication initially. The woman’s part in this? Although cautious at first, she finally begins to trust this person and gets closer to him, expresses her love and devotion and agrees to trust him fully. Monday things are perfect, Tuesday too and out of the blue on Wednesday the guy makes a 360 degree turn and changes completely. Can someone’s serious feelings be transformed so suddenly? Looking at his age it’s not as though he is going through adolescence! How do you see it? Shouldn’t he at least give an explanation or even some kind of excuse no matter how lame it may sound? By the way there is NO pressure from the woman, no hurry for anything.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

19 Answers

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

There is a reason. Or there is fear.

lillycoyote's avatar

He’s found someone else? It could be a number of things. Whatever’s going on, he sure as hell owes somebody an explanation, whoever this question is really about.

ZEPHYRA's avatar

@Simone_De_Beauvoir fear of commitment? But that is just what he wanted, that is why he agreed to meet. He was looking for marriage material and claimed to have found it!

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@ZEPHYRA There is claiming that’s what you want and facing a possibility of it happening.

ZEPHYRA's avatar

@Simone_De_Beauvoir yes, it makes sense. As soon as he saw the huge possibility of it falling into place, he got cold feet, right? Bit immature for a man his age I’d say!

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@ZEPHYRA This is always immature, no matter the age. If this is your situation, do not waste time on such a move. You’re worth much more.

ZEPHYRA's avatar

@Simone_De_Beauvoir Funny thing is, he tells her(immediate family member of mine)that he is so happy and his aim is the creation of family and that is what he’s been waiting for all this time. Previous relationships had ended apparently due to lack of communication and NOW, how lucky is he to have found the one he can communicate with!!!!!!!!!
Weird uh?

Bellatrix's avatar

For some people the excitement comes from the chase. The acquisition of something that was considered unattainable. Perhaps he was so wrapped up in persuading her that he was the one, that she could trust him, that he wanted her that when he actually got what he wanted, he finally stopped, thought about whether she is what he really wants and decided he doesn’t know. I call it “running for the hills”. The fear that comes when you realise this is serious. This really is the time when you have to decide to give your all or back away.

Would be good if some men would provide some insight here.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@ZEPHYRA Maybe he’s told himself this ‘creation of the family is my goal’ lie so many times, he’s believed it but his intuition tells his otherwise.

zensky's avatar

Cold feet.

Men are shallow, immature pigs.

LuckyGuy's avatar

Did they have sex on Tuesday? (The day before the mind switch.)

Bellatrix's avatar

I really want you to explain why that would lead to a mind switch @worriedguy. Really bad sex?

downtide's avatar

There is a reason, but it’s very immature of him not to tell her what it is.

A few possihbilities sptring to mind:
– he’s fallen for someone else.
– he’s already married to someone else.
– he’s discovered something (possibly from a third party) about the woman that’s put him off
– cold feet, afraid of the commitment
– something bad happened for him like he’s just lost his job or been diagnosed with a serious medical condition or something else that he doesn’t want to disclose to her.
– he has a longstanding secret that he doesn’t want to share and doesn’t feel he can continue with that secret hanging over his head

I’m sure there are other possibilities too but these are the ones that I can think of right now.

Ela's avatar

You stated “he agreed to meet.” and “how lucky is he to have found the one”. To me, this reeks of an online encounter and sounds like the A-typical dating site/chat room scenario. Is this where she initially met this “man”? Online?

ZEPHYRA's avatar

Not an online encounter. He made the major steps and promises, as soon as she opened up ready to trust, he turned the other way.

john65pennington's avatar

Identical situation happened to me. I was engaged to this girl and we were planning our marriage. Suddenly one night, she calls me to her house and returns my engagement ring. Repeated questions of why, never received an answer.

I later learned she had a twin sister in a mental institution. She never told me.

I am still puzzeled today as to why.

You are not alone.

Kardamom's avatar

This kind of thing happens every day.

In our society, women are programmed to want comittment and marriage. When they get married everybody is happy for them and they are told that they are lucky and blessed.

Men in our society are programmed to be aloof and make a lot of hook ups and are made to look weak if they want a comitted relationship. They are often called pussy whipped if they enter into a comitted relationship. If you listen to music or watch TV or movies, the media is constantly bombarding men, in our society, with the message that being single will get you everything you want and need, plus you won’t be tied down with responsibilities towards other people. Women, on the other hand are bombarded with the message that being single is a humiliating state and should be avoided at all costs.

This guy may have told the woman that he wanted marriage and a family, because they know that women want to hear that, and they are much more likely to give a man what they want if they think their relationship is heading toward a real comittment. So this guy may have just wanted sex and then after he got all the sex he wanted from this woman, he was ready to move on to the next one.

There’s all sorts of other reasons that this guy may have changed his mind.

He may have liked and appreciated the woman for all of her good qualities, but he may have never fallen in love with her.

He may have loved her at one point and then simply fell out of love with her, and he may have been just going through the motions for awhile, before he actually fled.

He may have fallen in love with someone else and simply not have told his girlfriend. That happens all the time. Next thing the dumped girlfriend might see is this dude with another woman on Facebook, or she might bump into him and his new lady around town, or she might hear it from mutual friends.

He might be gay. There are lots of gay men, who have not yet come out, that desperately want to be loved and to have a family, and they try to “act” straight, and may actually love their girlfriends, but when it comes right down to it, they realize that it just isn’t going to work. And these guys may never tell the dumped girlfriend the reason why, because it would just be too humiliating for them. The gay guy, may never even have a relationship with a man, either. Some poor gay fellows end up living lonely, solitary lives.

He may have realized that even though he wants marriage and family, he’s simply not in a position (in his own perceptions) to be in the right place finanacially, or emotionally. And he may have some fears and ideas about his own perceived inadequacies, that he would never share with his former girlfriend, because it would be too humiliating.

He may have been bombarded by messages from his close friends and family that the girlfriend was not good enough for him (for whatever reason) and he either agreed with them in the long run, or simply couldn’t see himself marrying someone that his family and friends didn’t like, no matter how much he himself may have loved the woman. Some people just don’t have that kind of strength, and the thought of alienating one’s own family is just too big of risk to take.

He may have realized that the girlfriend changed in some subtle or not so subtle ways that were very un-appealing to him after he told her that he wanted marriage and family. I know one of my work acquaintences became this horrific bridezilla about 2 seconds after her fiancee proposed to her. They got married and she became a horrilbe, b*tchy, comlaining, demanding wife.

He may have found out some disturbing information (true or untrue) about the girlfriend, and instead of discussing it with her, he just bailed. That kind of thing happens all the time.

He may have looked back at his parents successful or unsuccessful marriage and decided that he could never live up to the good expectations of their good marriage, or he feared that it was inevitable that he would fall victim to the bad expectations of their bad mariage.

He may have realized that the media messages are likely to be true for him, that he doesn’t need marriage and a family to get his needs met. If this was the case, he probably didn’t want to hurt the girlfriend’s feelings by telling her that she wasn’t necessary for his happiness, and instead he just left, without telling her. He either didn’t realize or care that his actions would hurt the girlfriend.

He may have witnessed the collapse of a close friend’s marriage and got spooked by that and decided that he didn’t want to even risk having that happen to him. So he just bailed instead.

He may have done something awful in his past (could be something major or minor) that he thought was long buried, but now has come to light again and he doesn’t want to have to explain to the girlfriend what happened, because it would be too humiliating, or he thinks that the girlfriend or her family would ultimately reject him when they find out about this “thing.” So instead of talking it out with her, he just flees.

So there are all sorts of reasons, some better than the others, for why a guy would change his mind out of the blue about wanting to get married and have a family with his girlfriend.

rebbel's avatar

“Wednesday the guy makes a 360 degree turn and changes completely”
I think you meant 180 degrees :-)
A reason can be that the guy had reservations about the relationship from the start or rather about his feeling of love for the girl and all the initiatives that he took (starting the relationship, and about commitment) could have been ways of pushing/forcing himself to see whether the love would come eventually.
When he found out it didn’t he didn’t get a real feeling of loving her he suddenly decided/found the ‘guts’ to end it all.

ZEPHYRA's avatar

@rebbel YES! 180 degree turn is just what I meant. I was simply affected by the whole situation that I witnessed so closely! BUT precisely the night before he had told her things were fine and going smoothly making all sorts of promises!?!?!?!?!?

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther