Social Question

JLeslie's avatar

What do you think about a student exchange program within the US?

Asked by JLeslie (65416points) August 21st, 2013

Similar to international student exchanges, but this would be domestic. The student can go to a different region of the US for a few months. It might be a student who lives in a rural area going to a large city or vice versa. Could be someone from the northeast trying out the deep south. Basically, anything is up for grabs that would be a new experience.

Would it help a new generation of people in the US be more open? Be more understanding of problems around the country and help them become adults with a better understanding of the different challenges and positives things around the country? Would the students enjoy it? Do you think it is a good idea? Would you want your kids to do it?

If you like the idea would you want it to be a summer program or a semester in school? What grade do you think is best?

If you have already heard if such a program I am interested in knowing about it.

Thanks.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

9 Answers

gailcalled's avatar

There are dozens of domestic exchange programs for college students already in place.

Source See the links in the first half of the site only. (The second half lists the foreign exchange programs.

None seem to be designed for high school students.

There are a few programs but they are school-specific, such as this one at Princeton Country Day School

In some high schools an enterprising and energetic guidance counselor might be able to set things up. Some high schools also have independent projects as part of the curriculum where this could be arranged.

johnpowell's avatar

I wouldn’t object to something where you do a year of community service someplace and maybe get 50% off your first year of tuition at college. Voluntary of course, I’m not a Socialist, actually I am.

janbb's avatar

I know a high school student from New Jersey who lived in a very privileged suburb and undertook on his own to live in Newark and attend an inner city high school for a semester. The students at that high school were a bit angry when his subterfuge was revealed. He had pretended he had moved there and afterward wrote about his experiences. He did get into Brown though.

WestRiverrat's avatar

Our school does this with a partner school, it helps they both have residential care (boarding school) programs in place.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

I like the idea a lot.

JLeslie's avatar

@gailcalled I actually was not thinking at the college level, but I failed to exclude that in my original post. It didn’t occur to me. I was just thinking 7–12.

gorillapaws's avatar

The closest thing I could find was this.

gailcalled's avatar

This isn’t exactly what you are asking about since it deals only with NYC low-income kids having a summer experience in the country and does not ship privileged kids into the inner city.

The Fresh Air Fund

Hawaii_Jake's avatar

I was an international exchange student during my university days for one year. I spent it in Japan, and it changed my life. I am a fanatical supporter of international exchange programs and foreign language study by extension.

In fact, my daughters and I hosted two Japanese junior high school students while they were here studying English just this past few weekends. (No, I didn’t speak any Japanese to them until their departure when they were quite surprised.)

Personally, I think international when I hear the word exchange. Honestly, I don’t think going from one part of the country to another is in the same league. Despite our many differences, we are one culture. An exchange program is meant to bring about fundamental experiences. Going to university does that already, but going to one in the same country, in my opinion, would not provide the necessary shift at the foundation level.

I have been writing about tertiary education, but I would say the same applies for secondary education, too. Spending time away from one’s mother culture and immersing oneself in another is the core of any exchange program. I simply don’t see how that idea would be served by staying in the same country.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther