General Question

Pirentuo's avatar

Are there limitations to federal law?

Asked by Pirentuo (56points) April 30th, 2014

Does federal government have the powers to legislate in all areas of society or do the states have exclusive privilege in some? If not, what are the limitations of federal law?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

8 Answers

jerv's avatar

Many lawyers get paid millions of dollars fighting over this exact question. However, according to some interpretations of the Tenth Amendment, the states reserve all rights not explicitly granted to the feds.

Of course, some states try to use this to make an end-run around federal (or international) laws, which is where the real fun starts and the shocking headlines appear.

Response moderated
GloPro's avatar

It is not uncommon for the federal government to pretend to give states choices, but if the preferred choice is not followed the federal government will withhold funding. The legal age for drinking is a good example of this. Federal law prohibits purchase of alcohol for anyone under 21, but allows states to set the legal age of consumption. For those states choosing to uphold this age for consumption as well, the federal government adds 10% funding for roads and transportation.
It’s a limit, but not really.

janbb's avatar

Whatever is not expressly denoted as federally controlled, is reserved by the states to legislate. That is the way the government was established. However, there are always fights about where that line is.

Strauss's avatar

@janbb However, there are always fights about where that line is. The largest fight like that was called the Civil War.

bolwerk's avatar

What @jerv said.

Also, most federal power to regulate state affairs comes from the current expansive jurisprudence surrounding the U.S. Constitution’s commerce clause, which may or may not violate the spirit of the clause (I personally don’t think it violates the letter of the law here). In at least one case, SCOTUS decided any impact on the market impacts interstate commerce, even if the transaction took place entirely within a state.

But there are lots of broad powers granted to the feds anyway: transportation, patents/copyright, money (I’m hesitant to say monetary policy), defense, foreign relations, etc.

weeveeship's avatar

And then there is this interesting doctrine:

Answer this question




to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther