Social Question

filmfann's avatar

Have I broken a law here, and what are my options?

Asked by filmfann (47850points) October 2nd, 2014

Someone owed me a lot of money, and paid me with a check from their home loan. I deposited it in the bank on Friday, and the bank put a hold on those funds until Tuesday.
On Tuesday, I went to the bank and had a cashiers check made, using the money I had just deposited. The bank manager and the teller both came to the window, and told me the check I deposited on Friday was now okay to use. I took the cashiers check to another bank, and paid off my house.
On Wednesday, the bank notified me that the first check I had deposited had bounced, and due to the cashiers check, my account was now overdrawn tens of thousands of dollars. The bank took all my savings to partially cover the overage, and I now have no access to money. On the other hand, I have inadvertently gotten an unsecured loan for tens of thousands of dollars they have no way to collect.
While we straighten this mess out, I am asking:
What if I walk away? Have I committed a crime like Bank Fraud since this was caused by the banks mistakingly approving drawing on funds they said were okay to use?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

18 Answers

marinelife's avatar

Since the check was no good, you are liable. Otherwise, anyone could go around kiting checks to get money. Since the bank told you the funds were available, I think they should drop the fees. I“m sorry this happened to you.

tedibear's avatar

Once you endorse a check, you accept any and all liability for the item.

You haven’t committed fraud, but recovering the funds from the maker are, technically, your responsibility. I hope that your bank will help you with this process, but I don’t know that they have an obligation to.

If you just walk away from your obligation, then you may have legal trouble.

I wonder why they didn’t put a seven day hold on that check. But that’s the banker in me.

kritiper's avatar

File a claim against the issuers of the bounced check. That is illegal. Everything after that is for you to straighten out. Time to lawyer up!

janbb's avatar

What a mess. Sending a hug!

(Sent to Adirondackwannabe.)

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

The law usually reverts back to intent. The bank didn’t intend to make an usecured loan to you. So they can ask for the funds back, and if you don’t comply you’ll be the one in hot water. You have a claim against the ones that gave you the check. There are a couple of ways that checked could have been returned. Can you find out the reason.? What a mess. I always give big checks extra time to clear, but the bank screwed up too, so you shouldn’t have to pay any fees. Document everything very carefully. Good luck.

rojo's avatar

How do you go about getting the money back on the loan you paid off?

dappled_leaves's avatar

What @Adirondackwannabe says sounds right to me.

If you’re asking this as a thought experiment, I think that there simply isn’t a single outcome of for this situation, which every person would experience. Much of what will happen next for you will depend on your prior relationship with your bank and all of the other institutions involved, as well as how you interact with these people, both initially and as it unfolds.

If you were a new client at the bank, or if you had had repeated problems with maintaining a balance, or defaulting on your own financial responsibilities, or if you were acting angry or “twitchy” with them, you would probably be in a very different position.

Technically, even if worse came to worst, I think that they would reserve charges like “fraud” as a last resort – first, they would ask you to return the money, then sic collections on you, etc., etc. I think it would take a long while for anyone to press charges.

And I hope it gets resolved quickly for you! What an awful situation to be in.

bomyne's avatar

I’d say go to your bank manager. Be open and honest with him or her. They’ll advise you on the best course of action, and talking to them also lets the bank know you taking this seriously. I’d also advise keeping them (the same manager every time) in the loop.

ibstubro's avatar

I would go to the manager of your bank, explain the situation, and ask him to give you a loan against your house for the amount you withdrew to pay off the mortgage. At a rate less than the previous loan, as there are certain to be fees involved.

As far as I’m concerned you and the bank are equally at fault for accessing the funds too soon, and the goal should be to restore the situation to what it was a week ago.

KNOWITALL's avatar

YOu also have the right to sue the person who gave you a bad check for any fees accrued in this matter. Lawyer time.

filmfann's avatar

I got a call from the bank saying they found the mistake, and that everything will be set right tomorrow morning.
What a stressful 2 days!

Dutchess_III's avatar

Oh, @filmfann! My heart was starting to pound for you! So was the check OK after all?

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

Ugh, good. I didn’t have a good solution other than hope like hell you bank likes you and hasn’t discharged the collateral documents.

Adagio's avatar

I’m glad it’s all come right in the end, what an awful position to find yourself in, no matter how short lived : ^)

Dutchess_III's avatar

Man, I have a headache now!

ibstubro's avatar

“I got a call from the bank saying they found the mistake…”
Sorry for screaming.

That ice bag on your head should help, @Dutchess_III.

filmfann's avatar

For two days, we had my bank saying the check had bounced, and the issuing credit union saying the check had cleared. Yesterday afternoon the two figured out the problem (and neither lays claim to the mistake), and have rectified it. The fees for bounced checks from my account have been reversed. Now I have to contact those businesses that have the incorrectly bounced checks, and tell them to resubmit them, or give them new payments.
Both financial institutions refuse to give me a letter saying this was not my fault, since it would indicate it was their fault.
But everything is being put back together, and I am happy for the moment.

janbb's avatar

@filmfann Sorry you had to go through this but glad it’s clearing up.

Answer this question




to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther