Is it better to choose a career as an investment analyst or a financial trader?

I’m finishing up my master’s in finance, but I’m having trouble deciding whether I want to be a hedge fund investment analyst or a hedge fund financial trader. I am qualified for both, but my main conflict is choosing between the risks and rewards of each position. By risk and reward, I mean job security and salary + bonuses.

Based on the information I gathered locally, an entry level position as an analyst pays an average salary of $120,000 + $50,000—$100,000 in bonuses. The bonuses increase substantially based on how well you perform. An entry level position as a trader pays an average salary of $210,000 while the bonus is strictly based on performance. The salaries of both positions increase substantially when you’re promoted to a higher position.

The job security is a bit different. While traders have higher salaries, they’re more likely to be laid off if they’re performing poorly.

I would like to hear your personal experience or general opinion. Thank you.