General Question

Khajuria9's avatar

When can a child be given freedom?

Asked by Khajuria9 (2141points) July 18th, 2015

Especially a girl. In my home, if I ever say this statement that “This is my life course and let me choose the path for myself”. This statement comes as a severe shock to my violent father and he starts saying bad words in response saying girls should never be saying that this is their life. Girls can never be free. They can never do the things they wish to do, can never go and work where they wish to, can never date men, can never marry the guys they choose and so on! Do you think this type of behavior is okay?
And if not okay, what could be done?
And dont you think that this type of repeated behavior often filled with anger and violence on the part of the parents will leave a child mentally, psychologically and emotionally distressed and wanting him/her to rather practice the evil than trying to listen to their parents. Would you care to opine?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

marinelife's avatar

It sounds as if your father comes from another cultural tradition than the US. I personally believe that girls absolutely own their own lives and destinies, and should choose their own paths. But your father doesn’t, and you are living under his roof.

Here is what I would do. Do not argue with him. It is fruitless. You will not change his mind. You have to hold your own truth to yourself. If you believe it, that is enough.

Then I would get through high school. If you can, save up some money. If it is possible, go to college somewhere far away from home.

Then I would plan to break off contact for a while with my family. I would get my own job and apartment and life.

Khajuria9's avatar

Yeah Marinelife, I tried arguing and explaining but he seems so resistant! Hmm, maybe you are right but his words are so discouraging, he would say you cant go anywhere, you lack skills, you wont reach high in life and all that shit all the time.

marinelife's avatar

@Khajuria9 Ignore him. He is trying to keep you down. His words come from his own wounds—they are not really about you at all.

Look around you for other role models. For example, Alice Allison Dunnigan or you might find some of the information in this document helpful.

Hang in there.

ragingloli's avatar

Angela Merkel became chancellor of Germany.
What has he done with his life?

Khajuria9's avatar

No man, no wounds, he has had no wounds, he is quite well educated, is in a significant position and is an avid reader but is a biased personality. He is baised on religious matters, about girls and their freedom, maybe you can call him a male chauvinistic, and my mom is like a perfect servant of his, but I cant be.

janbb's avatar

What country do you live in, if I may ask?

wsxwh111's avatar

First I’d like to express my opinion on your last question—- Yes, I think it’s terrible.
And second, I think it matters more that when you are ready to be independent instead of when you should be independent. Thus, since you’re asking this question, I’m gonna go for now. I think you are ready to start to think for yourself and try to find what you’re looking for right now.

wsxwh111's avatar

And for a little more advice, you can try to google controlling people/ parents. I did it, too, and I remember there’ve been many articles/ advice/ researches about this. Some advice on how to deal with these situations/ people and to speak affirmatively for yourself and avoid stuck in the traps between their words can help.

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

You are not a child, you are an intelligent mature woman. He needs to deal with that, but I’m not sure he can in your culture. We can talk if you want.

skfinkel's avatar

I would also ask, like Janbb, where are you from? your father’s opinion sounds like out of a different time and place. It might be hard to counter such an argument if you are in a culture where that argument is the norm. In that situation, going against one’s parent might present a rupture that you don’t want. Perhaps, since he is a great reader, as you say, you could provide him with some literature to read that will open his heart and mind. But I would do this at a calm time, and not at a time when you are having a confrontation with him.

Khajuria9's avatar

skfinkel, no, I cant make him read, he would never listen, all he reads for is to gain power over others to control them better, he thinks he is the emperor. He would still say, no matter how many articles he gets to read that girls can’t own freedom, they are and should be slaves, to the parents at first, and to the ones they live with, next.
janbb and skfinkel, I am from India (This nation sucks)

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther