Social Question

Dutchess_III's avatar

What do you think of this draft of a letter of recommendation I was asked to send?

Asked by Dutchess_III (46811points) May 12th, 2016

A couple of my son’s friends lived with us for almost a year. One in particular had a place in my heart. We’ll call him “Alejandro.” Pretty sure his Mom was an illegal, but he was born in Wisconsin. He carried around his fierce pride in being Hispanic, the machismo, tough, don’t mess with him, all of it.
His Mom moved them often, state to state.
When he landed with us in 2003 or so he was heading down a bad road, but slowly he started to change and was really on the way to being a good man.

Just before high school graduation he left my house, left the town, left the state.

Next time I heard from him, in 2005, he was in jail in Illinois.
Then he got out.
Now he’s back in.
It’s for stupid shit, like burglary, but nothing violent, although he’s not afraid of violence.
He asked that I write a letter of recommendation to his attorney, because he doesn’t believe he used to be the kid he was, so I worked this up, for what it’s worth.

My only reason was to paint a different picture of him for the courts, or whomever reads this. I’m not applying for a job.

**************
To Whom It May Concern,

My name is Dutchess and Alejandro asked if I’d write a letter of recommendation. I told him I would be happy to.

I first met Alejandro in 2002 or so, when he and my son, Chris, were high school classmates. The first time Chris brought Alejandro home to meet me, I flagged my son off of him. Alejandro had moved here from somewhere else. I don’t know if it was an inner city or what, but I told Chris that Alejandro was just too tough, too street smart, had seen too much, too…something. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it, but he was trouble. I knew it.

Chris listened. He’s a good kid. But, six months later, there was Alejandro, in my house again…and he was changed. He was softer, easier, more relaxed. I don’t know if it was the influence the town had on him, because this really is a great little mid-Western town, a very gentle town (that’s the reason I moved the kids here in 1995,) but Alejandro was different this time. So I gave the go-ahead for the friendship, and Alejandro became part of my family, another son of mine, like all of Chris’ friend’s did. Mi casa es su casa.

Chris seemed to always search out the semi-motherless boys and bring them home, and at one point, for almost a year, I had four young men living with me, Chris, Alejandro and two other boys, rampaging through my house, eating my food.

Beside Chris, Alejandro was the hardest working, most responsible, most mature. He actually helped Chris and me keep the others in line and make them pull their weight, because they were on their own much of the time.

Alejandro is a natural leader, too. In fact, at one point, after an epic tussle over who got ride in the trunk of the car for a short drive, and Alejandro allowed a tie between him and Chris, I asked why he deferred to Chris when it came to certain issues, when I knew it was in his nature to take the lead.
He said, “Because you are Chris’ mom, this is Chris’ house and I will respect that.”

And respect us he did…well, except for that one time he stole the whole damn left over Thanksgiving turkey out of the fridge! I was pretty sure that there was only one kid who would steal an entire used turkey, leaving no trace of it, so I went straight to him. He was honest about the theft, though. He said he took it home to his mom and sisters. I yelled at him that he didn’t have to steal it, I would have just given it to him and to at least bring the damn platter back! And the platter did reappear a few days later, along with a thank you note from his family. Smh.

And…also, he flew his “colors” out the upstairs window. The Mexican flag. Cars would rumble by, slow and loud. I yelled at him he was going to get us all shot! He laughed, and confidently told me he’d never let anything happen to us, his family.
As a teacher, however, I kind of liked the idea of flying flags of different countries out the windows. I asked if I could track down a UK flag, and a Dutch flag and a French flag to fly out of the windows, but he scowled at that, said no. It would be bad for his “rep.”

Alejandro continued to grow, to mature. His grades were coming up, attitudes were improving. It was amazing. There was a light in his eyes that hadn’t been there before. I think he was starting to see possibilities in himself that he hadn’t seen before. The colors came down. No more turkeys were stolen. He began to turn his intelligence toward positive ventures. He became more active in school, and in school activities. At one point he was a volunteer for one of his teachers with something she was doing for the elementary school kids. He taught them to play some game…you’ll have to ask him the specifics.

I told him I told him several times that being bi-lingual would be a tremendous advantage when he started looking into careers. The first time I told him that he got pretty pissed, until I explained that “bi-lingual” means you speak more than one language.

But because of that, and because of his life experiences, he was seriously considering a career with the……… (wait for it…..)……. Sherriff’s department. His teachers were gladly writing letters of recommendations for him. He had the whole, honest world at his feet. I had such high expectations of him, more than anyone else, except my son. I was so excited at the man he was becoming. He fought a good, good fight.

Then, in the middle of the night one night, I was awakened by a knock at the door. It was his sister. The whole family was in the car. They were leaving, and they had come for Alejandro. I just felt the blood drain out of my face. I almost told her he wasn’t here, didn’t know where he was, but I knew he’d never forgive me for that. It was his decision to make.
I went upstairs, woke him up. He got very excited and jumped out of bed and started packing his few belonging. I said, “No. Don’t go.”
He said, “It’s my mama! I have to go.”
I stood at the bottom of the stairs, waiting. He came down. I tried to stop him one more time, tears in my eyes. I knew I’d never see him again. He just grabbed my hand, raised it up, kissed the back of it, told me he loved me, and he was gone.

Now you have him. How can we convince him it isn’t too late? He’s young. He can still do great, GREAT things with his natural intelligence and skills. And even the experiences he’s had since he left, even though they’re bad and they happened because he made bad decisions, can be a benefit, if he plays his cards right? How can we do that?

Thank you for taking the time to read this.
Dutchess
My phone number and shit.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

Response moderated
Seek's avatar

I’m not crying, YOU are crying.

chyna's avatar

Too much emphasis on his short comings and bad behavior.

Pied_Pfeffer's avatar

It’s really nice of you to take the time to attempt to stand up for this young lad.

The letter is too long. If you really want to help this guy out, contact his lawyer to find out what should be covered. If that isn’t possible, take @chyna‘s advice and cut out the negative comments and antecdotes. Make it less about you and more about the strengths of his character.

This is a wonderful opportunity to help out someone you know and care about, and I think it’s wonderful that you are doing it. Please keep us posted on how it goes.

Cruiser's avatar

I like that you stood your ground as a empathetic mother of your own who opened her arms and home to a troubled child. You guided him as best you could and when family showed up to reclaim their son…you stood tall and proud that you gave him the best he could. He earned credibility under your wing @Dutchess_III and there is little more you can do than to let this young man who touched your heart but fly away and find his own path….

This has to be very distressful for you…((hug))

CWOTUS's avatar

Don’t be cute. ”… (wait for it …)” and “Smh” have no place in this letter. Stick to the topic.

Don’t talk so much about your son. Yes, he’s your link to the boy, and depending on its relevance to Alejandro’s character some mention of that may need to be included, but the first half of your letter is about Chris, not Alejandro. Strike all of that and stick to the topic.

Don’t add so much anecdote about family life at the Dutch house. It’s irrelevant to Alejandro’s recommendation. (It might be relevant to know why he is spending so much time apparently living in your home while he has a home; it took me until Thanksgiving to realize that he was not an orphan or runaway.) It makes no difference to the reviewer how you manage to attract strays and what lovable scamps they all are and how you love the dickens out of them. Stick to the topic.

The heartrending story of his departure from your life does not add a lot to his recommendation. Stick to the topic.

As others have recommended already, don’t try to write Alejandro’s biography, “warts and all”. If it’s to be a letter of recommendation, then write a letter of recommendation. Stick to the topic.

Three paragraphs.

Your letter of recommendation should be chopped – ruthlessly – to three paragraphs, plus a conclusion (perhaps). It’s not a biography of Alejandro. It’s not a short story. It’s not a memoir of “My Life With Alejandro”.

Writing about his growth is perfectly apropos.

Writing about the changes that he made (for the better) is fine.

Writing about his leadership qualities and sense of honor and duty are excellent.

Stick to the topic. Edit, then edit some more, and don’t mention anyone but Alejandro more than once – if at all.

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

I totally agree with the comments above. While you may not mean any negative comments to reflect badly on this young man, your negative comments may be all some people will see. This isn’t a creative writing exercise. You need to be much more direct and concise. This isn’t about you or your family.

longgone's avatar

It’s a really moving story, but I agree with others – I would remove all the negative traits, and any evidence of the early concerns you had. I’d be left with this:

My name is Dutchess.
I first met Alejandro in 2002 or so, when he and my son, Chris, were high school classmates.

[insert why A needed help, but I’d focus on what probably went on inside him, not the macho stuff]

Chris seemed to always search out the semi-motherless boys and bring them home, and at one point, for almost a year, I had four young men living with me, Chris, Alejandro and two other boys, rampaging through my house, eating my food.
Alejandro was the hard working, responsible, mature. He actually helped Chris and me keep the others in line and make them pull their weight, because they were on their own much of the time.

Alejandro continued to grow, to mature. His grades were coming up, attitudes were improving. It was amazing. There was a light in his eyes that hadn’t been there before. I think he was starting to see possibilities in himself that he hadn’t seen before. He began to turn his intelligence toward positive ventures. He became more active in school, and in school activities. At one point he was a volunteer for one of his teachers with something she was doing for the elementary school kids. He taught them to play some game…you’ll have to ask him the specifics.
I told him several times that being bi-lingual would be a tremendous advantage when he started looking into careers.

Because of that, and because of his life experiences, he was seriously considering a career with the Sherriff’s department. His teachers were gladly writing letters of recommendations for him. He had the whole, honest world at his feet. I had such high expectations of him. I was so excited at the man he was becoming. He fought a good, good fight.
Then, in the middle of the night one night, I was awakened by a knock at the door. It was his sister. The whole family was in the car. They were leaving, and they had come for Alejandro. I just felt the blood drain out of my face. I almost told her he wasn’t here, didn’t know where he was, but I knew he’d never forgive me for that. It was his decision to make.
I went upstairs, woke him up. He got very excited and jumped out of bed and started packing his few belongings. I said, “No. Don’t go.” He said, “It’s my mama! I have to go.”

[If you can, I’d paraphrase the dialogue. I’ve spent a lot of time with lawyers. They tend to respond better to professional language, not the things that make @Seek (just @Seek) cry.]

I stood at the bottom of the stairs, waiting. He came down. I tried to stop him one more time, tears in my eyes. I knew I’d never see him again. He just took my hand, raised it up, kissed the back of it, told me he loved me, and he was gone.
Now you have him. How can we convince him it isn’t too late? He’s young. He can still do great, GREAT things with his natural intelligence and skills. And even the experiences he’s had since he left, even though they’re bad and they happened because he made bad decisions, can be a benefit, if he plays his cards right.

Thank you for taking the time to read this.
Dutchess
My phone number and shit.

Dutchess_III's avatar

Thank you for the suggestions, guys. I’ll work on it.

Dutchess_III's avatar

@longgone, I love you man, but I have to tell you that your comment “not the things that make @Seek (just @Seek) cry.]” was just mean spirited and totally uncalled for. It added nothing to the conversation. Nothing, but a little jab.

longgone's avatar

^ That was a joke. I thought it was obvious, sorry if it wasn’t.

Dutchess_III's avatar

OK, I sent two letters. I sent the long version for Jauvy, and a second shorter, condensed version for the attorney. JAVIER CALLED ME TODAY! Just a bit ago! He told me he laughed so hard over that letter, he said. Then he cried at the end. He let his “bunky” read it too, filling in some of the blanks, like the trunk ride, and he got a huge kick out of it. So I’m glad I sent it. He said he almost fell off the bed when he read the part about the sheriff’s department because he had completely forgotten about that!

Jauvy wants to take his GED courses, but math is kicking his butt. So I’ll try to help him out with that as best I can.

Anyway, thanks for the input guys. I’m so glad I sent it, and so glad to hear from him.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther