General Question

AstroChuck's avatar

Who would you like to see as the 11th Doctor?

Asked by AstroChuck (37609points) November 11th, 2008

Okay. Put on your nerd hats and dig deep.
As you Whovians out there know, David Tennant will stop playing the Doctor after the four Doctor Who specials (That’s right. No regular series 5. What a gyp!) air in 2009–10. So any ideas of who you’d like to see him regenerate into? I’m still formulating my list.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

50 Answers

shrubbery's avatar

I just had a sudden thought…. Ewan McGregor. I don’t know though. I’d have to think harder about that, it was only a split second train of thought that came into my mind when I read your question.

I haven’t really thought about it yet…. I’m still bemoaning David Tennant’s departure.

Lemme get back to you.

AstroChuck's avatar

I would love to see John Simm. That would be unlikely, however.
I was sorry to see him killed off as the Master.
(Yes, I know that the Master wasn’t really killed off. Apparently his “essence” was in that ring. But his body did die. Right?)

asmonet's avatar

SHUT UP. I’m not listening, Chuck!

It’s not frickin’ happening.

::pouts::

P.S. I totally heard that RTD loved Harry Lloyd from Human Nature/Family of Blood. I think he’s a terrible choice, good actor….but not right.

Does anyone know why there isn’t going to be a regular series? What’s up with that?

joeysefika's avatar

A list of potential doctors:
– ODDS ON NEW DOCTOR FROM PADDY POWER (3rd Nov 2008)
2/1 David Morrisey
6/1 Paterson Joseph
8/1 James Nesbitt, Chiwetel Ejiofor
10/1 Russell Tovey, John Simm
12/1 Anthony Head
14/1 Robert Carlyle, David Walliams
16/1 Richard E Grant
18/1 Richard Coyle, Aidan Gillen, Alan Davies, Sean Pertwee
20/1 Jason Statham, Harry Lloyd, Nigel Harman, Marc Warren, Jack Davenport
25/1 Julian Walsh, Adrian Lester, Alexander Armstrong
33/1 Julian Rhind-Tutt, Rupert Penry-Jones, James McAvoy
40/1 Bill Nighy, Stephen Fry, Ben Wishaw
50/1 John Barrowman, Ben Miles, David Suchet, Hugh Laurie
66/1 Gary Oldman, Matt Smith, Paul Bettany, Joel Beckett, Christopher Eccleston
80/1 Alex Kingston, Dean Lennox Kelly, Christopher Villiers
100/1 Ricky Gervais
150/1 Hugh Grant, Russell Brand, Vinnie Jones
200/1 Robbie Williams

personally I think that James Nesbitt would be fantastic!

AstroChuck's avatar

No. I only know that both Doctor Who and Torchwood are going to appear in specials only this next year. DW has the annual Christmas episode coming up, and then three more specials before he is bye-bye.

@joey-Hugh Grant?

joeysefika's avatar

Thats not my list – just one I just found it on a DW rumour site :link

azul's avatar

I would like to see his next incarnation be female. I think it would be really neat – same Time Lord, just with hips this time.

AstroChuck's avatar

I remember a rumor that Colin Baker’s Doctor was going to regenerate into a female.
Last time I checked, Syvester McCoy still had male parts.
Not that I’ve been checking Syvester McCoy’s parts.

Response moderated
AstroChuck's avatar

Whoa. What happened? That was weird.

El_Cadejo's avatar

@astrochuck John Simm is great. Have you ever seen Human Traffic?

AstroChuck's avatar

No. But I loved him as Sam Tyler.

joeysefika's avatar

Yeah, he was fantastic as Sam Tyler, just as brilliant as The Master. It’s a shame that he can’t be the Doctor.

Sueanne_Tremendous's avatar

Amazing how little I know about what goes on in this world behind my back.

shrubbery's avatar

Ooh looking at another list on that site I saw James McAvoy… mmmm, that would be nice!

Bsilver's avatar

Omg I would DIE if James McAvoy became the Doctor… sigh

I didn’t know know that it was confirmed that DT was leaving, thanks for ruining my dreams Astro… :-p (living in a news vacuum kinda helps sometimes)

EmpressPixie's avatar

I have a secret longing for it to be Mos Def. I think Anthony Head is out because it would mean the weird bat creatures won in a way.

I love 10th Doctor. I don’t want him to go!

fireside's avatar

@azul – I don’t think the doctor will be a woman simply because he has to get married in order to resolve the story line from Silence in the Library.

I think Hugh Laurie would make a pretty interesting Doctor. He’s got the right kind of attitude and facial expressions. He’s probably too big for them but it would be interesting.

I don’t know enough about British Actors to offer a solid guess here, but I would be willing to bet that we see an 11th and 12th Doctor within a couple of years.

Really going to miss Tennant, I thought he did an excellent job.

illprincipe's avatar

Bill Paterson. Let’s keep the Scottish Doctor thing going.

cwilbur's avatar

Sean Pertwee.

AstroChuck's avatar

That would be kinda neat. After all, Georgia Moffett (Peter Davison’s daughter) played The Doctor’s daughter, so why not Jon Pertwee’s son as Doc #11? Of course, then you’d have a Doctor in his mid-forties.

shrubbery's avatar

I was thinking and I would actually love it if Stephen Fry was the doctor.
And too bad Steve Carell is American…

Though I’m pretty sure the next one is going to be younger that David Tennant.

joeysefika's avatar

I can’t believe that Eccleston only lasted one season, in my opinion he was better than Tennant. DT would’ve be better if he had used his proper accent.

EmpressPixie's avatar

No! Gasp! DT is FAR better than Eccleston! Speak no more!

joeysefika's avatar

No, no, no, no! Eccleston was a better Doctor. I watch the 27th season over and over again just to see him! (they were very well written episodes too)

AstroChuck's avatar

Now that Little Britain is over, why not bring back the best Doctor ever?
That would be Tom Baker, of course.
Perhaps he might be just a little long in the tooth, no?

fireside's avatar

Maybe the Doctor won’t regenerate and he will pass the TARDIS to his daughter.
He could decide to get married and retire from saving the world, give his wife his sonic screwdriver and all.

Great question, AC

asmonet's avatar

@fireside: You realize that version of events would result in some seriously homicidal nerd rage?

fireside's avatar

@asmonet – maybe that is the reason for the delayed season…deferred nerd rage.

asmonet's avatar

@fireside: Well, in my case it’s only exacerbating the problem. Damn!

AstroChuck's avatar

How about Rufus Sewell or Craig Ferguson?

fireside's avatar

How about Sean Connery for a short stint?

joeysefika's avatar

Sean Connery is too old, he could be the doctors daughters granddad?

AstroChuck's avatar

Ooh. Ricky Gervais would make a great Doctor.

fireside's avatar

How about Jonny Depp?

joeysefika's avatar

@fireside, that wouldn’t work, he needs an English accent. Thats pretty vital to the whole doctor thing seeing as he was born in East London…. I mean Gallifrey

asmonet's avatar

@joey: Is it pathetic that I got a bit of nerd rage after East London and it ended once I saw Gallifrey?

As far as I’m aware the Doctor has always been played by a British actor. I think people would riot if an American was chosen. I know I would. And I’m from the US.

joeysefika's avatar

@asmonet, not pathetic in the least seeing as i had my only little subtle nerd rage at the mention of Johnny Depp as a Doctor

AstroChuck's avatar

@asmonet- Actually, David Tenant is Scotish.

asmonet's avatar

Eh, close enough. I forgot he was Scottish, I’m too used to him being all Doctor-y.

Some Scot is going to stab me with a longsword for saying they’re close enough, right? Yeah, I’m dead.

asmonet's avatar

@joey: Amen.

MacBean's avatar

@asmonet – I might do it, and I’m from the US, too. XD

asmonet's avatar

@Macbean: If you need weapons I have over 15 medieval and WWII weapons we can use. Just sayin’.

fireside's avatar

So Kevin Bacon is out?

asmonet's avatar

@fireside: ...

AstroChuck's avatar

How about Guy Pearce? I know he’s an Aussie but he is British born.

shrubbery's avatar

haha. and he has experience in time travel.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther