What's the best kind of indoor tanning lotion?

Preferrably one that doesn’t do that tingling thing, that freaks me out.

Right now I’m using something called “Puppy Love [with body blush]”, but it’s not doing much. I’ve also tried something called “Fabulously Bronze” that’s an accelerator, but I don’t really notice a difference from that, either.

Also, I realize excessive tanning=skin cancer, so please don’t bother to preach to me about it. I’d really appreciate answers from people who actually know what the hell they’re talking about/people who have tried different kinds of tanning products.