Can I freeze pudding?

Why not? Here’s a recipe.

Why not just go get some fudge cycles?

You can freeze it but you can’t thaw it out and expect it to be nice. If you want it soft, like frozen custard, then you would need to freeze it in an ice cream maker. Otherwise, freeze away, and chomp on it frozen.

Jello even sells a Pudding Pop maker for turning its pudding mixes into puddin’ sickles, so looks like it’ll work fine..

Sure freeze it , eat it frozen . Will it taste good , maybe not as good as you think .

Bill Cosby says YES!

i bet if you only freeze it for about an hour, it would be perfect! A little icicly, but not hard-as-a-rock. Yum! Now i want!

I would think with the milk and the slower freezing in home freezers, there would be some ice crystals. I did try freezing the Yoplait Whipped Yogurt as advertised and it was pretty good.

Do it!