Send to a Friend

OpryLeigh's avatar

If someone commits a crime in a country they are not a citizen of should they be tried in that country or sent back to their own country to be tried?

Asked by OpryLeigh (25305points) October 9th, 2009

I recently saw a programme in which a British man was tried and found guilty in (I believe) Thailand for smuggling a fairly small amount of drugs. He got 20 years in a Thai prison and the programme was documenting some of his time there.

If he had been tried in Britain the chances of him getting such a steep punishment would be extremely slim, a couple of years in prison at the most I would say at a guess and his quality of life in a British prison would be far better than in the filthy Thai prison that he is currently residing in.

I’m all for punishing criminals and, unlike a lot of people, I am not completely against prisons (although I firmly believe they should be used as rehabilitation and not just as punishment) but where do we draw the line and who should decide what punishment fits the crime?

Using Fluther

or

Using Email

Separate multiple emails with commas.
We’ll only use these emails for this message.