General Question

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

How to measure the true of a man?

Asked by Hypocrisy_Central (26879points) December 17th, 2009

There is a debate running between family members on just what measures a man. One thought was if you had a man who could not or would not hold a job, lived at his parent’s house, never paid back loans but could get and often had sex with women that those were the traits of a real man, or that he was more man then most.

The other thought was that a real man would be he who had is own place, paid back his loans, helped out is parents instead of living off them even if he did not have frequent sex or near none at all.

Which of those 2 examples do you feel runs closer to what a real man is suppose to act like?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

11 Answers

Response moderated
interjection's avatar

this is just a penis measuring contest if it is how many women a guy can sleep with.

@Haleth you beat me to it.

but I just go with the responsibility part of this scenario

LKidKyle1985's avatar

Wow, someone has a really twisted sense of what a man is. The first example sounds more like a kid to me. just because you can have sex doesn’t make you a man. Being responsible, having your own life, and especially helping your parents makes you a man. The other option just sounds like a loser to me. Working hard doesn’t make you a sucker, working hard makes you responsible.

Silhouette's avatar

“If there be any truer measure of a man than by what he does, it must be by what he gives.”

Men are measured by their character, their integrity, personal responsibility and their unselfishness. And, by unselfishness, I don’t mean sharing his penis.

Fyrius's avatar

You’re not being very impartial on this, are you? The way you phrase the question basically leaves only one option.
Not that I disagree.

I say what makes a man is the courage to do what his conscience tells him even when that’s difficult, scary or inconvenient; the strength not to give in to his own weakness. Integrity.

“You are what you do when it counts.” – Anonymous

I suppose this is closely related to responsibility.

Pandora's avatar

It really all depends on your point of view. I understand what you are saying but actually man number two is the traditionally accepted version of how a man should be.
Man number 1 (the couch potato whore) is only told he is awesome by the following people. And that is by other couch potatos who are not so lucky with the women and man number two who has a miserable marriage, and by females with really low self esteem.
Man number 2 (the hard working, responsible guy) is told he is less than a man if he is a go getter by man number1 and pals because they wish to feel superior in some way so they flaunt their failures as if they won some prize. Oh, look at me I don’t work and I have all the time in the world to have sex because of it and my mommy still pays my bills or my girlfriend does. However they are a bottomless pit of low self esteem and that is why some are abusive and try to control the little they have.
Man number 2 will is also called greedy because he is usually to smart and can see a leech approaching a mile away. I know a man like man number 1, he is married and screws around and depends on family to help support him and his family. The only reason people do is because they don’t want to see his children in the street. He constantly is risking his childrens well being by making them feel insecure about their future. He claims he is a good dad and provider but everyone knows hes a lazy bum, a horrible father and husband. This by no means will ever be the defintion of a man. Even a boy has more sense. Even a leech has some redeeming qualitys. This type of person does not.

janbb's avatar

Sorry – but this is really a question?

Nially_Bob's avatar

Though my perspectives on (what appears to be) the increasingly archaic concept of a “man” are rather poorly developed there is something my Father once told me which I feel is a reasonably apt answer to your question,
“A man is someone who prioritises everything he loves before himself”

doesnotmakesenseatall's avatar

The same way as one would measure for a woman, if. **smiles**

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

@Fyrius Lets just say it was loosly based on 2 known individuals, so the facts are as they are. ;-)

HTDC's avatar

I thought you learnt the first time after your slut question.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther