Social Question

janbb's avatar

Who's up for a game? I was thinking of trying a Fluther variant on the old Animal, Vegetable or Mineral.

Asked by janbb (62874points) May 15th, 2010

Here’s how it works:

1. The poster – I’ll start – thinks of something in one of the above categories and announces the category.
2. People post questions that can be answered with a yes or no answer.
3. Poster responds to each one so wait your turn.
4. Whoever guesses the answer correctly, goes next.
5. Item can also be in the category “Famous Person” in which case that is announced.
6. Poster can give hints if no-one is getting close.
7. Similar to the game Twenty Questions but we won’t count questions or guesses.
8. This is Social, but try to keep Meta or chit-chat to a minimum.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

388 Answers

janbb's avatar

The category is: Famous Person

shit's avatar

Male or female?

Fyrius's avatar

Golly. Oh, why not.

Is it an American person?

janbb's avatar

@shit Yes or no answers can only be given.

dpworkin's avatar

Too many fuckin’ rules.

shit's avatar

@janbb Sorry, my apologies. Is it David Cameron?

Fyrius's avatar

I’m just going to try every continent one by one. >:D
It is a European person?

susanc's avatar

Is it a female person?

Fyrius's avatar

Is he English?

dpworkin's avatar

Is it Arthur Godfrey?

shit's avatar

It’s David Cameron, it’s David Ccameron. She never answered that one!!!!

Fyrius's avatar

Was he in Monty Python’s Flying Circus?

dpworkin's avatar

Is it Lord Beaverbrook?

dpworkin's avatar

“No” what?

janbb's avatar

No, no and no. Ask more questions before guessing.

susanc's avatar

@dpworkin what do you want, “No SIR”?

Fyrius's avatar

Is he somewhere in the entertainment business?

dpworkin's avatar

Do these pants make my ass look fat?

janbb's avatar

One at a time is better. Yes, to he’s English, not to all the other guesses.

Fyrius's avatar

Is he an actor?

susanc's avatar

Is he alive?

dpworkin's avatar

Is he John Clees?

dpworkin's avatar

Oh, dead guy, eh? Did he ever make a silent movie?

susanc's avatar

Was he alive in any of our lifetimes? For example, in dpworkin’s extraordinarily long lifetime?

dpworkin's avatar

Did he ever appear in cinema at all?

Fyrius's avatar

You are now aware that in this thread there are three dogs interrogating one penguin.

janbb's avatar

@susanc Hard to believe e but not even that!

dpworkin's avatar

A lying, cheating penguin.

susanc's avatar

was he W Shakespeare?

janbb's avatar

@susanc Yes! Yes! Your turn and good luck with it!

dpworkin's avatar

That guy didn’t even write his own plays. And I’m getting back at you @susanc.

susanc's avatar

O god. I have to go though. I’m proud and happy to be the dog who defeated the penguin, liar and cheater though she is. You guys go. Good luck with it!!!!
Oh hey, dopwerookfy, don’t even try it. I’ll beat you to the punchnext time too.

janbb's avatar

Someone else want a go?

Fyrius's avatar

I’ll do it.
I’m thinking of a vegetable.

janbb's avatar

Is it a root vegetable?

Fyrius's avatar

Yes it is.

janbb's avatar

Is it white inside?

dpworkin's avatar

Does it have Alzheimer’s?

Fyrius's avatar

It most certainly does not.

janbb's avatar

(not my Mom then.)

janbb's avatar

Is it orange?

dpworkin's avatar

(that’s what I was thinking)

dpworkin's avatar

Is it generally eaten by human beings in Western culture?

Fyrius's avatar

It generally is.

dpworkin's avatar

Ahh! James Arness! The carrot!

Fyrius's avatar

Bit obvious, huh?
Your turn.

janbb's avatar

Give us a hard one, doggyworkin.

dpworkin's avatar

It is au fond animal.

janbb's avatar

Does it have other componet parts?

Fyrius's avatar

Is there one on your avatar?

dpworkin's avatar

@janbb That question cannot be answered yes or no.

@Fyrius It is much, much more subtle than that.

janbb's avatar

@dpworkin It is still a living animal?

Fyrius's avatar

Is there one on @janbb‘s avatar?

dpworkin's avatar

(Jan, I should have said, that answer has not yet been answered satisfactorily.)

janbb's avatar

Well he is fond of this animal.

Fyrius's avatar

Does it live on dry land?

dpworkin's avatar

Hardy-har-har. If you don’t pay attention to the clues, you will never guess the answer.

CyanoticWasp's avatar

Is it a single-celled animal?

dpworkin's avatar

@Fyrius that question cannot be answered yes or no.

janbb's avatar

Is it still extant in the world today?

dpworkin's avatar

@CW that question cannot be answered yes or no.

dpworkin's avatar

Jan, yes, if “extant” is loosely defined.

Fyrius's avatar

Does it exist in the real world?

dpworkin's avatar

@Fyrius There is currently a debate on that issue.

janbb's avatar

@dpworkin Does it exist now not in its prior form?

Fyrius's avatar

Is it metaphysical in nature?

dpworkin's avatar

@janbb that question cannot be answered yes or no.

CyanoticWasp's avatar

@janbb that question can’t even be parsed.

dpworkin's avatar

@Fyrius that question cannot be answered yes or no.

janbb's avatar

@CyanoticWasp I’ll parse you! Sure it can.

janbb's avatar

Is it a fossil?

dpworkin's avatar

BRB I have to get something out of the microwave.

CyanoticWasp's avatar

Does it eat carrots?

janbb's avatar

And write plays?

Fyrius's avatar

Are there extensive discussions on Fluther about its existence, where I keep saying there’s no reason to even consider the possibility and @mattbrowne insists the question is outside the scope of science?

janbb's avatar

Can it be very big?

dpworkin's avatar

@Fyrius You are getting warmer, but no.

dpworkin's avatar

Yes, very, very big, or extraordinarily trivial.

janbb's avatar

It it an act rather than an entity?

Fyrius's avatar

Is it a being featured mostly in ancient mythology?

janbb's avatar

what about mine?

Fyrius's avatar

Are its origins on the planet Earth?

Fyrius's avatar

@janbb
Are you thinking of “the beast with two backs”?

janbb's avatar

I am indeed.

dpworkin's avatar

@janbb no, and your previous question, that question cannot be answered yes or no.

Fyrius's avatar

Is it from outer space?

dpworkin's avatar

For this exercise we will restrict the answer to this planet in the absence of empirical, although not inferential evidence to the contrary.

janbb's avatar

Has it been claimed to be sited in outdoor areas?

dpworkin's avatar

Sited? that question cannot be answered yes or no.

janbb's avatar

seen, I mean.

Fyrius's avatar

Is it amphibious?

janbb's avatar

Is there only one of it in the world?

janbb's avatar

dpworkin is having a technical problem and will be right back.

janbb's avatar

@dpworkin is still having problems with his computer. The answer was “an idea.”

Want to do one, @Fyrius or should we wait for more people/ Are you still around @CyanoticWasp?

Fyrius's avatar

An idea?

ucme's avatar

Ok i’ll give it a whirl, famous person.

janbb's avatar

Let’s just see if @Fyrius has one first since it’s his go.

Fyrius's avatar

Nah, that’s okay.

I didn’t guess it, either. I just repeated what you said.

janbb's avatar

OK. @ucme Is it a man?

janbb's avatar

Is he alive?

CyanoticWasp's avatar

Does he now or did he ever eat carrots?

ucme's avatar

@janbb Very much so yes.

CyanoticWasp's avatar

Does he play for Manchester United?

Fyrius's avatar

Is he American?

janbb's avatar

Is he in politics?

CyanoticWasp's avatar

Did he pitch a perfect game for the Oakland Athletics?

janbb's avatar

Is he a musician?

CyanoticWasp's avatar

Has he walked on the Moon?

ucme's avatar

No & no

Fred931's avatar

Is he living in Antarctica?

janbb's avatar

Is he English?

ucme's avatar

@janbb Already been established he’s American @Fred931 No

janbb's avatar

Is he an entertainer?

ucme's avatar

@janbb Yes he is.

janbb's avatar

Is he a movie star?

ucme's avatar

The net closes in, yes.

janbb's avatar

Is he married to Angelina Jolie?

ucme's avatar

Ahh my dear sweet beloved Angie…ahem sorry distracted for a mo, err no he’s not.

TogoldorMandar's avatar

does he have sons?

ucme's avatar

@TogoldorMandar Yes,you changed your question.In the interests of fairness I therefore must amend my answer to no.He has one son.

janbb's avatar

Is it Martin Sheen?

TogoldorMandar's avatar

Is it Jermy Stiller?

ucme's avatar

No it isn’t

janbb's avatar

Kirk Douglas?

ucme's avatar

He’s not no.

Draconess25's avatar

Is he from Brooklyn?

ucme's avatar

@Draconess25 No fraid not @TogoldorMandar well define popular, i’d say yes.

TogoldorMandar's avatar

is he often in the spotlight?

ucme's avatar

Yes he is.

TogoldorMandar's avatar

you should give a hint now

ucme's avatar

Well seeing as you asked nicely,erm he’s from California.

Fred931's avatar

SCHWARZENNEGAR?

Fred931's avatar

plzplzplz…

ucme's avatar

Sorry but the answer has to be in the negative.

ucme's avatar

Ok, the answer is no not Arnie

janbb's avatar

Is he a humanitarian as well as a movie star?

ucme's avatar

@janbb No he’s not. Anyone ready for a fairly loud hint or you still good to go?

janbb's avatar

I got to go to RL soon so I’ll take a hint.

ucme's avatar

Okey dokey, he turned down the lead roles for Raiders of the Lost Ark, Jaws & Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Now that’s a very big hint right there.

TogoldorMandar's avatar

is it Harrison Ford?

TogoldorMandar's avatar

i meant George Lucas srry

ucme's avatar

You mean Indy in Raiders? That’ll be a no then.

ucme's avatar

Ah of course,still no i’m afraid.

ucme's avatar

No. I could of course end this with the biggest hint of all.

Draconess25's avatar

Danny DeVito?

TogoldorMandar's avatar

yes end it or you could pass me the magic word and ill take the honer what ya say?

ucme's avatar

@Draconess25 No sorry @Draconess25 Okay here goes, faster finger on the trigger wins!!

ucme's avatar

Although American, he has a connection with the French. Oh my god, the quarterback is toast!!! It’s a gimme I tell ya…...& the winner is?

ucme's avatar

G..e ..ck..n is his name.I give up too, i’m offline soon.

filmfann's avatar

Glen Beck?

ucme's avatar

Popeye, Lex…..

filmfann's avatar

Gene Hackman

filmfann's avatar

Waiting for positive confirmation before proceeding

ucme's avatar

Thank fuck for that.Congradulashuns!!

filmfann's avatar

Okay, I am thinking of an animal. Also a famous person.

Draconess25's avatar

Are they an animal & a famous person at the same time?

filmfann's avatar

Man is an animal

Draconess25's avatar

Well, you know what I mean!

Are they Asian?

janbb's avatar

American?

filmfann's avatar

No, though he lives here

janbb's avatar

Politician?

filmfann's avatar

No, though he has been mildly active in political stances, as the famous are want to do.
Also, I should say I believe he currently lives in the US, though I am unsure, but he definitly has in the past.

filmfann's avatar

He is European

ucme's avatar

Has he been involved in a scandal of any kind in the recent past?

filmfann's avatar

Yes, but in such a small story, it’s not worth considering. I am sure you are unaware of it.

janbb's avatar

You’re supposed to only give yes or no answers.

ucme's avatar

Is he in the film industry?

filmfann's avatar

@janbb yes but with this group we could do this all night
@ucme He has worked in the film industry, but is not famous because of it

ucme's avatar

A writer?

filmfann's avatar

@ucme he has written 2 books, but he is not famous because of it

janbb's avatar

Was he an explorer?

filmfann's avatar

@ucme he has written other things, I should note.

ucme's avatar

Is he British?

ucme's avatar

Andrew Lloyd Webber

filmfann's avatar

@ucme no
btw, don’t trust anyone with three names

ucme's avatar

Is he gay?

filmfann's avatar

@ucme, no, he isn’t gay

Draconess25's avatar

Is he over 50?

RedPowerLady's avatar

@filmfann Is it Simon Cowell?

filmfann's avatar

Ewww, No!

RedPowerLady's avatar

@filmfann Well I thought it fit, haha.

Is he considered good looking? :P

filmfann's avatar

@RedPowerLady I am sure some find him attractive, but not me.

Draconess25's avatar

Is he over 60?

filmfann's avatar

He is 69. You need a hint?

Draconess25's avatar

That number is following me everywhere! Is he overweight?

filmfann's avatar

@Draconess25 Once again, a personal call. I would say no. Others might say he could skip a few meals.

Draconess25's avatar

Okay, a hint?

filmfann's avatar

We have established
He is an Animal
He is a famous man
He his British, but lives in California
He is not grossly overweight, or staggeringly attractive.
He has written 2 books, but is not famous for that. He has written other things.
He has worked in the film industry, but is not famous for that.
He is 69 years old
He has had very mild political involvement, and isn’t known for it
He was involved in a minor scandal, but you probably don’t remember it. It wasn’t big news.

The hint is: He sang about War, and he is an Animal.

filmfann's avatar

No, and I have no idea who that is

RedPowerLady's avatar

can you tell I don’t know my actors very well? haha, i’m having fun playing though :)

filmfann's avatar

well, at least someone is…

ucme's avatar

Cat Stevens.

filmfann's avatar

It is not Cat Stevens.

filmfann's avatar

It’s funny. I was sure the hint was a giveaway. I am guessing you guys are just fucking with me by not answering this correctly.

RedPowerLady's avatar

Is he a singer then?

filmfann's avatar

Yes. A singer.

ucme's avatar

Eric Burdon

RedPowerLady's avatar

see i don’t even know who that is, haha

@ucme Your turn! What category?

filmfann's avatar

Eric Burdon was the lead singer with War and with Eric Burdon and the Animals.
He acted in the film The Doors, and wrote two books on his music career.
He currently lives near Palm Springs, California.
He has spoken out against war, and was involved in a minor scandal when his ex-wife burned down his house.

ucme's avatar

Err i’ll have to be quick as it’s after midnight here in England town. Sporting event is my category.

RedPowerLady's avatar

@filmfann Thanx, now I know :)

@ucme Is it a basketball event? wow that’s late

ucme's avatar

No,not sure if i’m allowed this category but if everyone is happy to continue then what the hell.

RedPowerLady's avatar

Does it have a ball?

ucme's avatar

No it doesn’t

ucme's avatar

No sorry

ucme's avatar

No, let’s cheat a little here.Think faster than swimming, much faster.

RedPowerLady's avatar

@ucme if you need to go to bed we can pick it up when your awake, no problemo, no need to stay awake for a fluther game, lol

RedPowerLady's avatar

I got it. It’s the INde 500

ucme's avatar

More specific & still way faster than that.Good god i’m not going to bed, the night is yet young.I do however need to go offline for the night, more interesting games to play ;¬}

ucme's avatar

Yay well done, quick & simple.

RedPowerLady's avatar

That was it?

ucme's avatar

Yep good guess,you must have read my mind.Ah well fun while it lasted, outta here.

RedPowerLady's avatar

@ucme Have fun playing your other games ;P

RedPowerLady's avatar

New Category: Vegetable

Draconess25's avatar

Make it easy, ‘cause I want a turn!

ucme's avatar

@RedPowerLady Oh I will, nighty night.

Draconess25's avatar

Is it round?

RedPowerLady's avatar

uh sorry my computer overheated

Not round

RedPowerLady's avatar

Uh let me google that

RedPowerLady's avatar

Okay I don’t know what shape that is. If it means oval like in longer than round then the answer is No.

Draconess25's avatar

Is it long like a carrot?

Draconess25's avatar

Is it broccoli?

Draconess25's avatar

Cauliflower?

RedPowerLady's avatar

No Very Close

Draconess25's avatar

Is it green?

RedPowerLady's avatar

Nope it’s harder than that to guess

Draconess25's avatar

Is it in the family Brassicaceae?

Kayak8's avatar

brocollini?

Kayak8's avatar

cabbage?

Seek's avatar

Bok Choy?

RedPowerLady's avatar

No none of those three

Draconess25's avatar

Kale? Brussel Sprouts? Turnips? Radish? Mustard?

RedPowerLady's avatar

No not those

RedPowerLady's avatar

It’s funny :)

Kayak8's avatar

horseradish is kind of funny . . .

RedPowerLady's avatar

Not horeradish, lol

jazmina88's avatar

peas, swiss chard

Kayak8's avatar

well, I know rapeseed isn’t funny . . .

RedPowerLady's avatar

huh? that’s not funny…

Draconess25's avatar

For a plant name it is….

Kayak8's avatar

A vegetable in the Brassicaceae family that is funny . . . wasabi?

RedPowerLady's avatar

So far we know it’s:
Green and in the Brassicaceae Family
It’s Funny and Not Easy to Guess
It’s not round and not oval and not ovaloid

Kayak8's avatar

Hairy bittercress? now that’s funny

RedPowerLady's avatar

@Kayak8 Very funny but that’s not it.

RedPowerLady's avatar

if you guys get frustrated and need a hint let me know

Kayak8's avatar

woad is me . . . will we ever get this?

RedPowerLady's avatar

It is possible b/c one of the things we know makes it very easy (to look up)

RedPowerLady's avatar

Hint is if you wikipedia brassicacae family you can get some help ;)
I noticed it when I looked up what the heck that was, lol

RedPowerLady's avatar

huh? not that whatever that is

Seek's avatar

Mustard?

Kayak8's avatar

Isatis tinctoria

RedPowerLady's avatar

Nope, not that hard!

RedPowerLady's avatar

I can give another hint if you need it.

Kayak8's avatar

collard greens

Woad is Isatis tinctoria

RedPowerLady's avatar

No, sorry, that’s not it

Seek's avatar

What’s funny about vegetation?

Kayak8's avatar

Is it every child’s favorite veggie, brussels sprouts?

RedPowerLady's avatar

you’ll see :)

Draconess25's avatar

Model organism?

RedPowerLady's avatar

Nope on either

Kayak8's avatar

kohlrabi?

RedPowerLady's avatar

Okay I have to get ready to go somewhere so I have to give a hint if we don’t get it. Sorry.

RedPowerLady's avatar

No not that

RedPowerLady's avatar

Hint: It’s a hybrid. That is why it’s funny.

Kayak8's avatar

broccoflower

RedPowerLady's avatar

You win :)
I’ve seen the stuff in real life, it is funny stuff, trust me :)

Draconess25's avatar

How’s it taste?

Kayak8's avatar

I have to say that I think kohlrabi is pretty funny!

RedPowerLady's avatar

No way, I didn’t say I cooked it, haha.

RedPowerLady's avatar

Okay have fun!!! Sorry I have to go :)

Kayak8's avatar

@Draconess25 You said you had one if you want to go ahead, I am late in coming to the game . . . I get the general rules but not the particulars . . .

Draconess25's avatar

Okay….an animal!

Kayak8's avatar

mammal?

janbb's avatar

335 responses and not one GQ? Just sayin’

Seek's avatar

Is it bigger than a chicken?

Seek's avatar

Does it have feet?

Seek's avatar

In that case, I’d want to say “Lizard”, instead of delving further and naming a more specific animal.

Draconess25's avatar

Nope.

Wait, there’s legless lizards?

Seek's avatar

The Glass Lizard is legless. Though, it’s smaller than a chicken.

Seek's avatar

Okay, a non-mammal, non-bird animal, bigger than a chicken, and comes with and without feet.

Seek's avatar

Is this animal currently extinct?

Draconess25's avatar

Some species.

Seek's avatar

I think I need a hint.

Seek's avatar

A reptile, larger than a chicken, that may or may not be extinct, and may or may not have feet.

Seek's avatar

The Loch Ness monster?

Seek's avatar

“Zeffie”? The Lake Zephyr monster that some drunken hillbillies near me swear they’ve seen?

Seek's avatar

Let’s not deny the obvious:

Dinosaurs?

FutureMemory's avatar

A sea turtle.

Draconess25's avatar

No, it’s not a turtle.

FutureMemory's avatar

Dang, I really thought I had it.

Some don’t have feet (flippers); larger than a chicken; some species are extinct; reptile.

Draconess25's avatar

Need a hint?

Kayak8's avatar

komodo dragon

Seek's avatar

Dragon?

FutureMemory's avatar

A normal dragon? The kind that flies around breathing fire and all that.

Kayak8's avatar

monitor lizard

filmfann's avatar

If I may suggest, this game might be better in a chat room or a different string, since it has gotten so long, and takes time to load.

Draconess25's avatar

Dragon, but not all fly or breathe fire. Knuckers don’t.

FutureMemory's avatar

@Seek_Kolinahr beat me by 4–5 seconds.

Fred931's avatar

@Seek_Kolinahr @FutureMemory If you’re willing to break the rules/not interested in coming up with something, I want a go. I have one that you guys will never ever guess. But I don’t think you’ll give up that position, though it never hurts to ask.

Draconess25's avatar

Awww, let ‘im!

Fred931's avatar

Hell yeah. Ok…

Fred931's avatar

Famous (In A Sense) Person

Seek's avatar

((Thanks for carrying on without me. I had to put the youngling to bed))

Fred931's avatar

Yes.

You’re welcome @Seek_Kolinahr.

RedPowerLady's avatar

are we still playing?

Fred931's avatar

F*ck yes.

RedPowerLady's avatar

Is he on TV?

RedPowerLady's avatar

Is he in movies?

Fred931's avatar

Fluther won’t let me say no. But I need to say no.

RedPowerLady's avatar

Haha, lol. When I was answering I had to make longer answers too.

Is he infamous?

Fred931's avatar

Yes. And I’m sorry that you’re the only one playing. That was a disappointment for me, too.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther