Social Question

Blackberry's avatar

How do you feel about revealing a magicians tricks?

Asked by Blackberry (31779points) May 21st, 2010

Some say it is harmless entertainment, and revealing their illusions puts them out of business, others say it is simply an illusion in the first place and will be discovered eventually.

Are you for or against revealing magic tricks?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

lucillelucillelucille's avatar

Against.Definitely against. I don’t want to know how David Copperfield makes his panties disappear. no,no,no

mattbrowne's avatar

Totally in support of it when dealing with superstitious people. Magic is an illusion. All tricks have a natural and scientific explanation.

If people are not superstitious and just want to enjoy the shows no revelations are necessary.

ucme's avatar

I’d rather reveal their spleens utilising a rusty blade & a blow torch.I don’t care for magicians at all.

ratboy's avatar

Penn & Teller do it inoffensively.

gasman's avatar

I’m with @mattbrowne—there is such enormous superstition and gullibility and scientific ignorance in the world that it makes sense to reveal how easily we are fooled. What’s the difference between a so-called psychic and magician? None really—they both perform tricks that defy the senses and produce an altered sense of reality.

The magician however, states up front that he/she is performing an illusion for the purpose of entertaining you, and people applaud the performance for the brilliant art that it is. Psychics, by contrast, performs the same tricks and claim they’re real—and plenty of idiots believe them.

silverfly's avatar

I don’t really care either way. Revealing the trick does kill it though so I guess if you like magic tricks, it’s bad. I think we should really ask that magic be titled something else like visual deceit. So, magicians can be called visual deceit…ists. And they can perform visual deceits. :) “Tonight! I will perform visual deceits unbeknownst to all man! Visual deceits so daring and dangerous blah blah blah”

YARNLADY's avatar

Most people understand that magicians are simply entertainers who utilize the tricks of optical illusion on stage instead of in the movies. If you are a fan of “how they did it” you will enjoy see the answer, but if you would rather just enjoy the spectacle, you won’t.

@ucme Your comment is way over the top – my father was a magician, and I was his assistant during my teens

El_Cadejo's avatar

Understanding a magic trick doesnt really make it any less magical to me. I know its just an illusion in the first place, when i know how it works, it if anything adds to it because im impressed with the skill generally required to pull off such an illusion.

roundsquare's avatar

@uberbatman Really? I feel differently lots of times. When the trick is something creative, learning how it was done makes it more amazing to me. But lots of times it ruins it, especially when the trick is “the spikes in the door are connected to a computer that has them retract so that it only looks like…”

Joybird's avatar

Lets just say I have that walking on water thing down and I’m not telling you how it’s done. LOL

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther