General Question

rovdog's avatar

What is the best configuration for data transfer between two external hard drives?

Asked by rovdog (842points) August 23rd, 2010

I often have to connect external hard drives via firewire to my mac and daisy chain them together because of lack of ports. If I want to transfer the fastest from hard drive A to hard drive B, what is the best configuration. Should hard drive A be hooked up to the computer and hard drive B be hooked up to hard drive A? Or should hard drive B be hooked up to the computer and hard drive A hooked up to hard drive B? Or does this not make any difference? Right now I’m transferring TBs of data so I want any advantage I can.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

8 Answers

anartist's avatar

If they are usb, use 2 usb ports directly connected to your computer and move other usb peripherals to a hub to make room. I have 2 WD Tb Mybooks and use the Smartware software for backup.

actuallery's avatar

There is no real advantage. the data being transferred still uses the main computer as a transport device, even if you think the data is going directly from one external to the other external. The best thing, though, would be to disable the anti-virus software and firewall, disconnect any other usb devices, including internet, and not have any programs running. Also, make sure that the ports you are using are version 2 and not 1.1 as might be the case for some usb port cards or front usb ports, or hubs.

Dr_Lawrence's avatar

For such huge amounts of data I would consider temporarily installing the drives to ide or sata internal connections for the duration of the transfer.

actuallery's avatar

There might be a problem or a slow response if your mac does not have a huge volume of “free space”. As I said previously, the data from A to C to B runs through the free space of C (ie mac). Just let it run overnight, i expect such a huge volume would take about 6 hours to transfer. Maybe boosting your ram might also help.

rovdog's avatar

Thanks everyone. So the free space on your mac matters? I let it run overnight- I just want to understand for future transfers. Say I did have enough ports- as I do on another mac which isn’t here right now- is it faster to hook both of them up to the mac© than it is to daisychain? If I have a firewire 400 port and an 800 port is it better to hook up A or B to either.

actuallery's avatar

All you can do is try the configuration. Trial & Error is the best way to do things, at least so that next time you will know, for sure, the best or better, way. By the way, how long did it take to transfer?

rovdog's avatar

I don’t know because I did it overnight but it said it would take about 8 or 9 hours- this was three volumes of about 300–400 GB each.

actuallery's avatar

Perhaps you should consider getting a PC rather than using a laptop so that you can, as @Dr_Lawrence suggested, attach them as slaves rather than externals. It would reduce the trnasfer rate by about a quarter. Not that much time saved but if you need your laptop and it’s all rigged up, you cannot stop or cancel the copy transfer without losing or possibly corrupting files.

Answer this question




to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther