General Question

Ponderer983's avatar

Do dogs learn better or more quickly with other dogs present?

Asked by Ponderer983 (6416points) September 9th, 2010

Like imitation learning. As humans, we sometimes learn by example and imitation, where we observe what other people are doing and that knowledge forms in our knowledge base. It got me thinking, does this happen with dogs as well (or any other species of animal for that matter)? For example, when my dog wants to go to the bathroom, he goes to the door and whines. I never taught him to do that, but he just does it. I was speaking to a friend who has 2 dogs, and she expressed how she can’t seem to teach the second dog how to let her know when it has to go to the bathroom, but the other dog does it. Shouldn’t the 2nd dog observe what the other one is doing and learn from it?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

13 Answers

15acrabm's avatar

puppies, no
older dogs, yes

WestRiverrat's avatar

Dogs are like kids in the sense that what works for one may not work for another. Some dogs learn by repeating something until the lightbulb goes off. Other dogs can just see one dog getting rewarded for doing something and picking it right up.

Mom2BDec2010's avatar

I used to have an inside dog then got a puppy and he learned what to do when he wanted to use the bathroom by watching our older dog, so yes its possible.

john65pennington's avatar

No. other dogs present were interferring with our border collies learning techniques, so they had to go. he could not concentrate on the learning subjects at-hand.

woodcutter's avatar

this is the first time we’ve had two dogs at the same time. Our pup who was doing fairly well until we rescued an adult dog from the incinerator. There is too much distraction it seems. The pup wants to run and play whenever the other dog is near and doesn’t seem to listen as well. it’s all good but I think if the dog you are working with has only you to listen to it will do better.

WestRiverrat's avatar

Woodcutter, my dogs have to be seperated when I am doing formal training. They are easily distracted by what the other dog is doing if I try to work them both at the same time, especially if it is new stuff I am teaching them.

I use some of our play time to get them to honor commands they have mastered singly when they are together or other dogs are present. But when teaching them something, they tend to learn better one on one.

rooeytoo's avatar

Obedience training is best done in groups because the other dogs act as distractions and it gives the trainer an opportunity to train out bad behavior when the dog interacts instead of obeying.

In a home situation, it truly does depend on the dog, some learn by imitation others need direct instruction.

So there is a definite maybe for an answer!!!

downtide's avatar

I think the presence of strange dogs is often too much of a distraction for good learning, but an older dog in the household, who already knows the skills, will help the younger ones learn. @rooeytoo makes a good point though – the presence of distraction in a training class is a good thing because it gives you the opportunity to teach the dog to not respond to distractions.

marinelife's avatar

They have different learning styles just like people, but I know that my greyhound observed my other dog and learned a lot of things from him.

Including whining when he wants to go out.

Neizvestnaya's avatar

Having two more dogs around has helped my dog relax enough to be open to learning to swim so yes on something like that. As far as potty training though he’s still a dirty little bastard who insists on peeing on the patio rather than going off like the other two to further parts of the yard.

Plucky's avatar

It really depends on the dog…and the dogs around that dog. Just like people :)

MaryW's avatar

It depends on the dog and what you are hoping that dog to learn. They are so different in personality and learning and temperment.
As a teacher the human must be realistic to their dogs abilities and dogs as a species. The hardest part of the relationship is to be consistant with the training and it helps if you have time.
As for dogs learning from each other, sure they do. On our farm I can tell you that they learn some things interspecies too. Animals have a great capacity for thought and for working within a family, pack, herd, or flock. It all works if the human can honor each species nature and set rules of acceptable behavior. It works well if it is fun for you.

happy123's avatar

both because when a dog sees the other dog doing something and receives a treat he/she will do the same but when alone you give full attention to one dog and maybe will learn faster.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther