Do men and women agree on what makes a woman attractive?

This question was prompted by the “High Heels” thread. I can’t remember ever being attracted or repulsed by a pair of high heels, per se, even though I like fashion and I notice shoes. Nor do I think most ordinary women are “too fat”, or wish them to have the body of a professional model. (I prefer regular size.)

Do women do extraneous things to themselves in the mistaken belief that they must, in order to be attractive to men? How much do we notice, guys? Has eyelash length, or fingernail perfection ever been a deal-breaker for you?