I like these two guys... I don't know which one to choose... Can you help me find their qualities?

My two best friends, Fuzzy and Lil’ Brother ( those are their nick-names) are my 2 crushes. I can’t choose between the two and I made a list of pros and cons. Here they are: Fuzzy: In my school, plays the violin and always plays my favorite song, Told me I’m pretty, likes to make me laugh, comes to my lunch table everyday and talks to me, Looks at me all the time, never made fun of me, he’s stuck up for me, and is totally comfortable with telling me how he feels. Lil’ Brother: Moved away, talked to me every day and joked around with me, whenever I saw him in the hallway he’d be like, ” HEY!! I KNOW YOU!! Highfive!” and he’d give me a high five and a hug… HE looks like Taylor Lautner.. Here are some cons: Fuzzy: mean at times, not very good looking, broke up with me in 4 days. Lil Brother: Moved away, he’ll say, ” Yeah, I’ll call you in 10 minutes” and that ends up being 2 weeks. HAs lied to me alot, when I ran into him, he only said,” Yeah sure” when I asked for a hug and then walked away because everyone from my school was crowding him because no one had seen him in a long time. I don’t know which one to choose… What would you do?