General Question

HeroicZach's avatar

How do you integrate (indefinite) the product of two distinct terms, both containing x?

Asked by HeroicZach (195points) March 21st, 2009

I’ve got a really weird dilemma. I have to learn how to indefinitely integrate things with two distinct terms.

So like the indefinite integral of x^2 times the cos(x^3) is something I would need to be able to do. Is there some sort of a product rule in reverse for integration?

And yes, I need to know how to do this for my homework, all of you who will freak out and go “DO YOUR OWN HOMEWORK!!!!” I want to learn the concept, not get an answer for my homework, so please, if you can help, do so. I’m not a lazy kid that just wants to put an answer down – this stuff isn’t even graded.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

2 Answers

Jayne's avatar

Well, the answer to this problem is sin(x^3)/3+C. When you differentiate this function, the chain rule comes into play, so the derivative of sin(x^3) is cos(x^3)(x^2)3, and you need to divide the entire function by 3 to cancel out the 3 at the end.

With experience you will be able to tell this just by looking, and recognizing that you have a function containing a second function, and the whole thing is multiplied by the derivative of that inside function (multiplied by a constant. this part is very important; if the derivative of the inside function is multiplied or divided by x or any other variable term, this technique will not work. But constants carry through, and indeed can be put outside of the integration/ differentiation process entirely, thus posing no problem). This is, of course, what you get when you use the chain rule to differentiate something. All you need to do is run the chain rule in reverse.

To formalize this process, use “u-substitution”, about which there is plenty of information on google. However, this only works for the situation I outlined above. There is an infinite number of multiple-part functions that require other methods to integrate, or are impossible to integrate explicitly by any means. Integration follows no hard and fast rules like differentiation, and is ultimately a matter of intuition, educated guesswork, and luck. So, good luck, and feel free to message me if you need more help.

BonusQuestion's avatar

Nice answer @Jayne.

@HeroicZach, there is no general “product rule” or “quotient rule” for integration. In addition to the substitution rule which is a method that sometimes works, there is also Integration by Parts that sometimes helps us integrate the product of two functions. I am not sure if it is covered in your class or not so I won’t comment further. But you can find a nice explanation here. Integration by Parts is generally considered an analogue of the Product Rule for differentiation.

P.S. Generally speaking you can very easily come up with functions that are “impossible” to integrate, which makes integration “harder” than differentiation. Example: exp(x^2).

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther