Send to a Friend

troubleinharlem's avatar

Why should we learn Spanish for people who don't have respect for our country?

Asked by troubleinharlem (7991points) January 28th, 2011

First of all, this is not my question. This was a question posed by one of my friends that I didn’t have an answer for.

And here’s our conversation:

<bbbearcat> but you’re right, mexican spanish sounds horrible compared to spain spanish. but you kind of have to know it now.
<bbbearcat> Or at least, it gives you a leg up.
<Abdiel> No, I don’t.
<bbbearcat> No?
<Abdiel> I worked in places in California
<Abdiel> I seriously don’t care.
<Abdiel> If they can’t bother to follow the rules of citizenship, then I don’t care.
<Abdiel> I would never move to France, for example, without learning French.
<Abdiel> It’s disrespectful.
<bbbearcat> But you can learn it through immersion.
<Abdiel> We’ve got more illegals in this country than Denmark and Sweden have a total population COMBINED
<bbbearcat> True, but that doesn’t mean that they are bad, right?
* Abdiel shrugs.
<Abdiel> They have no respect for our country
<Abdiel> The Latin Americans I know that went through the citizenship process hate the illegals more than any racists.
<bbbearcat> Just by not learning the language before they came over?
<Abdiel> No, for trivializing what it means to be here, to be part of this country and community, for not even trying to integrate, but still expecting welfare and such
<Abdiel> I mean, I’m not racist by any means, ethnicity doesn’t define you, but living up to stereotypes is incredibly frustrating for me. The time I spent in California was almost exhausting on my tolerance of such things.
<bbbearcat> I’d say that they’re part of the community. Hell, they pay sales and property taxes and most pay federal and state taxes as well.
<Abdiel> It’s a mixture of principle, and the fact that it’s a disregard of the law
<Abdiel> Its not that I don’t empathize with wanting a better life. It’s that I don’t think its right to just expect to ignore the laws of a place and not bother to even start the process of becoming legal, but just expecting to work the system and make it accomodate you
<Abdiel> And continuing to pour across the border and abandon their home country and then proclaim all kinds of pride and cultural importance afterwards is so contradictory it boggles my mind.
<bbbearcat> They’re only leaving their home country because right now it’s so awful to live in.
<Abdiel> Then fix it.
<Abdiel> I know that’s incredibly callous
<Abdiel> But fleeing in the millions doesn’t help

So… what do you think?

Using Fluther

or

Using Email

Separate multiple emails with commas.
We’ll only use these emails for this message.