Which girl is more compatible, why?

So theres this guy:
Sun Aquarius 27.06
Moon Pisces 15.37
Mercury Aquarius 16.31
Venus Pisces 22.29
Mars Gemini 8.18
Jupiter Leo 6.14 R
Saturn Aquarius 1.05
Uranus Capricorn 12.18
Neptune Capricorn 15.47
Pluto Scorpio 20.23
Lilith Sagittarius 22.16
Asc node Capricorn 27.58

And this girl:
Sun Libra 16.07
Moon Pisces 17.05
Mercury Scorpio 2.38
Venus Scorpio 17.08
Mars Cancer 14.00
Jupiter Virgo 29.43
Saturn Aquarius 11.51 R
Uranus Capricorn 14.09
Neptune Capricorn 16.14
Pluto Scorpio 21.30
Lilith Aquarius 29.13
Asc node Sagittarius 23.46
Ascendant Cancer

Then this other girl:
Sun Aries 4.39
Moon Aries 26.29 OR Taurus [hard to tell]
Mercury Pisces 10.38
Venus Aries 16.09 R
Mars Cancer 15.59
Jupiter Libra 10.28 R
Saturn Aquarius 25.56
Uranus Capricorn 21.45
Neptune Capricorn 20.56
Pluto Scorpio 25.20 R
Lilith Pisces 17.50
Asc node Sagittarius 15.10

Who do you think would be more compatible with the guy astrology-wise. Why? Why do you think so?