Send to a Friend

Jellie's avatar

Is torture ever justified?

Asked by Jellie (6492points) August 18th, 2011

Consider this situation (a likely situation nowadays I would assume): one of the state authorities/security forces/intelligence have apprehended a man who has admitted to being privy to information about a planned terrorist attack which will kill hundreds of thousands.

The authorities know that if they torture him he will give up the information (let’s assume this fact is a given) and they will get to save many many lives.

What do you think? Should they? Would you?

Using Fluther

or

Using Email

Separate multiple emails with commas.
We’ll only use these emails for this message.