Would you accept an offer to send your child to a Christian based private high school where 87% of the graduates go on to top ranked colleges, or leave them in public high school?

Say there is a private Christian based high school with a 5 star education ranking and 87% or more of its graduates go on to and are accepted in top ranked colleges across the US. You have a benefactor wiling to sponsor your child and pay the steep tuition. Do you take the offer or pass because the religious connection the high school has, educational excellence notwithstanding?