If you had a daughter, say, in the 4th grade, and another kid was physically bullying her, would you encourage your daughter to physically fight back?

Inspired by another thread where a Jelly’s 4th grade son is being bullied. The son doesn’t want to fight back, but several of the men are advising the dad to encourage his son to fight back,like one good punch, to end it. But the kid doesn’t want to fight back. He just wants it to stop. Poor kid. It caused me to wonder if they’d give the same advice to the father if it was his daughter being bullied.