When both/all choices are equally good or bad, how do you make a decision?

And I don’t mean “eanie-meanie-miny-moe” or flipping a coin. I’m extremely indecisive, and if I try these types of methods, I’m never happy with the outcome. I’ll do it over and over again until I get the other outcome(s), and then I won’t be happy with that answer, either. What would you do?