Two first homecoming dates?! Help!

I am a freshman, and a Sophomore I am in Drama class and club with asked me to homecoming. The thing is, there is a classmate I’ve known for a long time, and was expecting him to ask me. I was honestly not thinking of going to homecoming. But after remembering I wonder if the classmate even thought about going with me.

The sophomore is so sweet and social, and even offered to buy my ticket and bring me to dinner before the dance. I got so happy but didn’t want to sound easy so I told him I’d think about it.

These boys don’t know each other so no drama or rivalry could happen, and they both have their own charms. I really don’t know what to do. Tomorrow I’ll hint at my classmate to see if he wants to go to homecoming with me… But if he does ask, who should I choose?

The romantic sophomore who reads me like a book and will probably be a fun, social date? The only downside being that he has no courage to ask these things in person and asked me through text.

Oooor the tall and caring freshman who has been there with me through some rough times, and will be more introverted like me during the danice?
The only downside being that his antisocial tendencies may make me feel like he isn’t having fun, plus I may have to find a way to buy my own ticket…

I need help with this. What would you do?