What first motorcycle should I get?

I just passed my MSF course (yes!) and I’m now looking for a bike.

I’m not sure if one exists like this, but I’ll throw it out there:

Basically, I’m looking for a nimble bike that isn’t styled like a crotch rocket. I’m a beginner, I learned on a Buell Blast, which I really enjoyed actually—it just looks a little sporty for me. Aesthetically, I’m really drawn to the ‘60s-style cafe racer Triumphs, like the Thruxton or Bonneville.

Things I’m looking for:
* Fuel economy
* Power—I really don’t need a bunch. At all. I’m rarely going to be taking it on the highways. I am, however, sizable and athletic (6’1, 195lbs). The 493cc Blast had plenty of power for me.
* Handling—Like i said, I’d like something a little flickable.
* Price—As a first bike, I don’t mind getting used or older bikes—provided they’re reliable.

Also, any advice about buying your first bike is welcomed too!